You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Sun, Mar 7, 2010 : 5:29 a.m.

Making 415 W. Washington an arts center would be good business decision for Ann Arbor

By Tamara Real

On Feb. 1, the Ann Arbor City Council voted to invite the Allen Creek Greenway Conservancy and the Arts Alliance to partner with it in developing a Greenway Park and Arts Center at 415 W. Washington S. The lack of affordable space for arts studios and professional exhibition and performance space in Ann Arbor was cited as one of the reasons for undertaking this initiative.

Since then, some have questioned the value of investing in artists. Unlike cultural organizations, which are easy to spot and whose economic impact can be readily calculated, artists are tougher to categorize. What is known about artists as a sector, however, provides compelling evidence that developing 415 W.Washington  as an arts center makes good business sense.

"Artistic activity is often viewed as a discretionary element in a regional economy, rather like icing on a cake of industry, finance and basic services," writes Ann Markusen, director of Regional and Industrial Economics at the Hubert H. Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs at the University of Minnesota, in her ground-breaking study, The Artistic Dividend: The Arts' Hidden Contributions to Regional Development (2005). 

This is an impoverished view, she argues, suggesting that "the productivity of and earnings in a regional economy rise as the incidence of artists within its boundaries increases, because artists' creativity and specialized skills enhance the design, production and marketing of products and services in other sectors.

"Artists also contribute to what economists call the economic base of a region -- the goods and services exported out of the region that enable the producers to earn incomes that are in turn spent on support of local-serving businesses as well as on imports of yet other goods and services," Markusen goes on to say. "Artists contribute to this economic base when their work and performances are paid for by consumers and businesses elsewhere."

Artists as significant contributors to regional economic vitality can be found in many art centers, with the oldest and best-known being the Torpedo Factory Art Center in Alexandria, Va. Formerly a munitions factory, the facility houses 82 studios, six galleries, and two workshops serving 165 artists. It welcomes approximately 500,000 visitors annually who purchase artwork, take classes, and engage in a host of other income-generating activities, such as shopping and eating in nearby establishments.

If 415 W. Washington were to be developed along these lines, there is no reason to think artists would have a less favorable impact on our community. 

According to study The Creative Economy in Washtenaw County, produced by Ann Arbor SPARK in 2008, artists and other members of the creative economy already generate 10% of the county's entire payroll and account for 4.6% of the county's total work force. If such numbers are the result of benign neglect, just think of the impact that could take place if artists were allowed an affordable, safe place to work!

To receive periodic updates on the proposal to develop an art center at 415 West Washington, contact Tamara Real at The Arts Alliance, (734) 213-2566.

Comments

Mark

Thu, Mar 18, 2010 : 10:21 a.m.

Hey now, what's all this disagreement about. Tamara sites examples of how communities benefit greatly from artist participation and visibility. This is not a subsidy situation. This is a reasonable accommodation. Mike, many artists have studios in their homes. Not a whole lot of glass blowers or people working in large sculptures. Should taxpayers subsidize sports stadiums, museums, schools, churches? Sure there is room for debate. Each of these can make a strong argument and there are folks that would argue against each too. Put me down in the strongly in favor of supporting culture category.

lf

Thu, Mar 18, 2010 : 10:19 a.m.

What a fantastic concept. The Torpedo Factory is a cultural desination that has spurred on other developments in that sector of Alexandria. The Washtenaw County Artist Space study of 2005 showed that there was a great need for space desired by visual, performing and literary artists. This can and should be an economic driver for cultural tourism in the region.

mike from saline

Fri, Mar 12, 2010 : 8:46 a.m.

I don't pretend to speak for anyone but myself!! And there is nothing in my statement that should lead you to believe otherwise. I made a simple [and factual] observation. If you'd like to hang out with other "artists", so you can see, and observe what they're producing, so you can grow, and learn, I say, "have at it"! What are your obstacles? Do you think the tax-payers are obligated to build you an "art colony"? As for the "Technology Center", yes I saw it. I thought it was a mixed bag. Some good stuff, some mediocre, and lots of crap!

gowongo

Thu, Mar 11, 2010 : 1:50 p.m.

Mike in Saline, Thanx for speaking for all the artists. One point of a large building with different artists is to foster an art community that can grow and learn from one another. Being an "artist", I would welcome the opportunity to see what other people are producing in their own spaces. Had you been to the technology center (the site where the Y is now) before it had burned down? I'm guessing not.

mike from saline

Mon, Mar 8, 2010 : 6:02 a.m.

What kind of studio space are we talking about? I know a lot of "artists" [visual arts]. Everyone I know has there studio [or work place] in there home. There is realy no demand for this. Once again Tamara Real gets away with submiting the same editorial every month. It's getting a little stale.

Thick Candy Shell

Sun, Mar 7, 2010 : 10:56 p.m.

Of course there is no designs in hand. The building was condemned by the city in the mid 1960's and no changes have been made since then. The building is filled with black mold, asbestos and Lord knows what other toxins. The building needs to be demolished and then discuss what can be done.

Jens Zorn

Sun, Mar 7, 2010 : 9:53 p.m.

A promising idea, particularly if studio space were affordable. Given the times, cost will be a major issue. Are there any preliminary design sketches in hand? Has anyone made reasoned estimates of costs for renovating/adapting the space? Is it envisioned as being self-supporting in the long run? It is certainly true that this project would complement the Y in bringing activity to the West Washington area.