You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 5:07 a.m.

Cleveland Orchestra returning to Hill Auditorium for Schumann, Wagner and Bartok

By Susan Isaacs Nisbett

Cleveland-Orchestra.jpg

The Cleveland Orchestra comes to Hill Auditorium Tuesday, Feb. 1.

photo by Roger Mastroianni

Ah, winter. Ah, Cleveland. As in the Cleveland Orchestra.

Having been around Ann Arbor a long, long time listening to concerts, when I spied the great Cleveland Orchestra on the University Musical Society schedule Feb. 1, I immediately thought back to the 1995 season.

That year, when the Cleveland was in town for a February residency, it was only at the last hour — literally — that piano soloist Emanuel Ax managed to free himself from an East Coast blizzard to arrive at Hill Auditorium for the Brahms Piano Concerto No. 1. Earlier in the day, the Cleveland had put out an all-points bulletin for a pianist to replace Ax — handily settling on then-University of Michigan Professor Anton Nel, who had the music in his fingers and his fingers near Hill. He impressed the Cleveland’s management so much that though he didn’t play that night, he was engaged to appear with them at a future date.

PREVIEW

The Cleveland Orchestra

  • Who: The Cleveland Orchestra, Franz Welser-Möst, conductor; Pierre-Laurent Aimard, piano.
  • What: Schumann Piano Concerto, Wagner's "Overture to Tannhäuser," Bartok's "Music for Strings, Percussion and Celeste."
  • Where: Hill Auditorium, 825 N. University Ave.
  • When: Tuesday, 8 p.m.
  • How much: $10-$75, UMS Ticket Office in the Michigan League, 734-764-2538, and online at ums.org.

Well, there’s a concerto on the program the Cleveland, under Music Director Franz Welser-Möst, presents here Tuesday. It’s not Brahms, but rather Schumann, and the pianist isn’t Ax but rather Pierre-Laurent Aimard, who is touring the U.S. with the orchestra this season. So the good news is, if they make it, he should, too, and they’re all coming from Miami.

There’s more good news than that, of course. Item 1 might be the chance to hear Aimard, a performer whose technique and musicianship, in both classic and contemporary repertoire, should make this Schumann concerto exceptional. Item 2 might be the concerto itself, a partnership between piano and orchestra that allows both to shine in the manner Schumann envisioned as an ideal, with “the autocrat at the keyboard (revealing) the richness of his instrument and of his art, while the orchestra, more than a mere onlooker, with its many expressive capabilities adds to the artistic whole.”

(Note: Later on in February, when pianist Rafal Blechacz appears with the chamber ensemble Concertante for the Chopin Piano Concerto No. 1, UMS patrons will hear a concerto that adheres to a very different model, in which the piano is clearly king.)

013011_WELSERMOST.jpg

Franz Welser-Most leads the Cleveland Orchestra.

photo by Roger Mastroianni

If Aimard, Schumann and the Cleveland are not sufficient lure, there is the rest of the program to entice.

It should be a treat to hear the Cleveland play Wagner’s “Overture to Tannhäuser,” a work of immense grandeur and power that has been a stand-alone orchestra favorite since its composition. And the journey from the Schumann concerto to the Wagner overture and then to the exhilaration and color of Bartok’s “Music for Strings, Percussion and Celeste” should make for exciting travel.

It may not be as on-the-edge-of-your-seat exciting as wondering if the soloist will make it to town, as happened in 1995, but that’s the kind of extra-musical drama we’ll be glad to forgo.

Comments

James Leonard

Thu, Jan 27, 2011 : 1:14 p.m.

Dear Ms. Nisbett, I read with interest your preview of the Cleveland Symphony Orchestra's impending appearance in Ann Arbor under their music director Franz Welser-Most. I'm sure many folks will read your preview and anticipate the concert with pleasure. Not me. Though the Cleveland Orchestra was once one of the top five orchestras in America, it lost that distinction when it hired Welser-Most. Anyone with ears to hear could tell that, including your former colleague at the Cleveland Plain Dealer, Donald Rosenberg. "Former colleague" because Mr. Rosenberg was removed from his post as the Plain Dealers' classical music critic after he pointed out in his reviews Welser-Most's lack of talent, ability, and taste. And to make matters worse, Rosenberg was removed at the behest of the Cleveland Symphony. I vowed after that to never attend another concert by the Cleveland Symphony. And I would have thought that a conscientious music critic, feeling solidarity with one of their number who was treated so badly, would have felt the same way. James Leonard