You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Tue, Jan 3, 2012 : 5 a.m.

Can 'playing favorites' be justified?

By Carolyn Hax

Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Dear Carolyn:

You've written about relatives who play favorites—that's me! My older niece appreciated everything I ever gave her. Her younger sister felt entitled to everything and never, EVER said thank you—not even when I left work to pick her up for school when she missed her bus. When she turned 18 I stopped sending gifts, doing favors, everything.

Her older sister noticed and felt guilty. The younger sister simply cut me out of her life. I was only useful to her when I was giving her what she wanted. People may want to simply appreciate generous relatives.

— Favorite-playing aunt

Of course. But there are also situations where the favoritism is capricious and cruel, sometimes even driven by the gift-giver's psychological need to secure an ally and create a rift between the haves and have-nots. Just ask siblings of a favorite who could do no wrong, and who was used to remind everyone else of their failures. In those cases, seeing the aunt as "generous" is a slap in the face to her designated have-nots.

--0-- --0-- --0--

To Aunt:

Please knock it off. The more sensitive, conscientious of the two sisters is the one you are hurting. Swallow your righteousness and give some love to the less pleasant sister (who may actually need it more for the fact that she's able to ask for it less), if for no other reason than for the sake of the nicer sister who aches to solve this problem and has no power to do so.

— Anonymous

Your "who may actually need it more" insight could be its own thread.

Sometimes people really are selfish, and that may be the case here, but I also think it's common for people to ascribe simple, negative motives where more subtle and complicated things might be happening.

For example, the accessible charm of the older sister may have bestowed on the younger sis an entire childhood of being overlooked, ignored, misread, incrementally black-sheeped. By the end of the process, black sheep are easy to write off—"She's so entitled!"—but what about those points along the way when adults could have acted like adults and made the extra effort, possibly pre-empting a future where Black Sheep wants no part of family?

Certainly enough there for debate.

--0-- --0-- --0--

Re: Favorite-playing:

I have five young nieces and nephews. Some seem incredibly shy, others not. The 3-year-old won't speak to me and hides behind my sister.

I've always tried not to force things and let my sisters' children come to me when we're together. But now I'm having a hard time not favoring the youngest, who actually seems to like having me around. And I'm having an increasingly hard time not taking the 3-year-old's action personally. Which seems incredibly dumb for an adult to do. Thoughts on a way to get right with this?

— Anonymous 2

You're already most of the way there, just by catching your bias (you're being a little hard on yourself, even).

Best thing you can do is remind yourself there are great people in both the introvert and extrovert camps; the former just need you to work a little harder to get to know them, because they don't have an inner force driving them into your lap.

Email Carolyn at, follow her on Facebook at or chat with her online at noon Eastern time each Friday at