You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 10:35 a.m.

No cake at a wedding? Perish the thought!

By Mary Bilyeu

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Bilyeu
A good friend of mine, Cindy, attended a wedding recently. She shocked me with some astounding news, so it's a good thing I was already seated or I might have keeled over and knocked a tooth out when I collapsed onto my desk: There was no wedding cake.


C'mon, join me — clutch at your chest as your eyes bug out, gasping for breath as though all the air has been punched out of your lungs.

No ... cake? No cake! It's a sacrilege! There has to be cake at a wedding! Guests ooh and ahh over it, vie for the best pieces, hope to get some of the edible decorations. Brides and grooms indelicately shove some into each other's mouth. Cake at a wedding is a tradition!

But perhaps not so anymore? Cindy said that people she spoke with that evening told her that there hadn't been cakes at other weddings they'd attended recently, either.

weddingcake.jpg

Mary Bilyeu, Contributor

I'm sufficiently ancient and decrepit that my friends and relatives have either been married for 30 years or they're divorced, and our children aren't yet old enough — please, God, make sure they're aware of that! — to get married. So I admit that I'm not an authority on this subject.

I hadn't been to a wedding in years until attending one in July, and thankfully there was a cake. (Who knew it was now possibly considered optional?) It was really good, too, with luscious creamy white frosting ... But I digress.

I've known of people who offered tiers of cupcakes that were arranged to resemble a cake. I've known people who offered an array of treats and sweets in addition to the cake, but the cake was still a major attraction.

Cindy said that other desserts were available at the wedding. There just wasn't a cake, and from what she can gather, having no cake is becoming a trend. So, in horror, I started to do some remedial and less-than-scientific research.

Here is an assortment of quotes and responses gathered when I tossed this life-altering notion out into cyberspace and sought comments via Facebook and Twitter (so excuse grammatical/spelling quirks inherent in trying to type on a phone or cram a message into 140 tidbits!):

What else would the bride shove up the grooms nose? ;-) Seriously, yes...cake, of some sort, is a MUST!

What are people going to do, cut into a cupcake or a cookie? Sheesh!

That is ridiculous! If anything I have heard people turning to options but not getting rid of cake entirely! Thumbs down!

Haven't heard this in the UK, though some friends had tiers of cheese instead.

I don't know if I want to go to a wedding that doesn't have cake. It's a travesty!

We had cupcakes as our cake and then an ice cream sundae bar with cookies and brownies and no one ate the cake! We had like 100 cupcakes left over. Maybe it's true :-(

Shut up!

Some things are just wrong, this is one! weddings=cake

Not any weddings I've been to.. no.. wait.. there wasn't a wedding cake at the most recent one. Probably because the bride and groom didn't want to spend $1,000 on a cake.

Plus, you have to save the top of the cake for your first anniversary! I have such fond memories of our wedding cake — made at a Swedish bakery in Minnesota with lemon filling... and it's been almost 36 years!

So, there you have it — I'm apparently not alone in feeling weak and dizzy at the notion of not getting my cake fix at the end of the festivities. Deep sigh of relief.

I also did a search and found a website called Exquisite Events Seattle that addresses the cake-less issue:

"Cake has dominated the wedding industry for years. However, right now there is a growing trend to skip the cake all together. Maybe cake is not your thing. For many people cake is okay, but they have a dessert that they simply swoon over. So, why not have that dessert at your wedding?"

Why not? Because people expect a cake and want a cake! And they won't leave your ceremony talking about how beautiful the bride was, but instead will leave talking about how deprived they felt at being denied cake!

I am fully aware that there are more earth-shattering and life-altering situations taking place in the world than not serving cake at a wedding, just in case anyone was wondering. However, this clearly struck quite a nerve for many of us.

In my obsessive compulsion to learn more about this issue, I've discussed it with many people who are in their 20s and 30s, those on "the wedding circuit," in other words. Almost universally, there has been cake at the receptions they've attended. One of my co-workers told me that she's never been to a wedding that didn't serve cake.

Cindy (who may regret, at this point, ever having mentioned this to me!) brought up the issue of the Jewish dietary laws, and having to serve a non-dairy cake — which is very often inferior — with a meat meal.

 In that instance, settling either for the lesser cake or for a vegetarian meal wouldn't make for an optimal situation. The better dinner served without a cake might easily take precedence over the butter-less dessert.

So finally, as my brain was starting to hurt from all of this contemplation, I consulted a true expert: my favorite baker, Bryant Stuckey of Decadent Delight. Here's his professional opinion:

"I don't know if I would say it's a trend, but I have had many instances in the last couple years where couples have forgone the wedding cake ... I think this is to stay within their budget. It seems a shame to me... I just can't see a wedding without a wedding cake. The wedding cake is another character in the wedding. It's symbolic to an idea of a 'sweet life' together."

I think the notion of cake playing a role and symbolizing a sweet life together is absolutely perfect. And I think that symbol should be enjoyed with all the loved ones who've joined the happy couple on their special day, literally and figuratively sharing that sweet life with all of those who have been — and will continue to be — integral to it.

So skimp on the rose petals that flower girls toss along the aisle; they're just going to get ground into the rug or the runner anyway. Do away with having 14 bridesmaids and save money by not ordering so many bouquets. Don't bother with an ice sculpture that will just melt. There are so many non-essentials at weddings.

But cake — cake is an absolute! It's a classic that never goes out of style. Change the shape, the colors, the flavors, and even the doohickeys that go on top.

But never, ever shun the cake! And if you do, please know that I will not be offended if you leave me off the invitation list.

Mary Bilyeu has won or placed in more than 60 cooking contests and writes about her adventures in the kitchen. She was thrilled to have her post about Scottish Oatmeal Shortbread named as one of the daily "Best of the Blogs" by the prestigious Food News Journal.

Go visit Mary's blog — Food Floozie — in which she cooks, reviews restaurants and generally enthuses and effuses over all things food-related. And feel free to email her with questions or comments: yentamary@gmail.com.

The phrase "You Should Only Be Happy" (written in Hebrew on the stone pictured at the top of this post) comes from Deuteronomy 16:15 and is a wish for all her readers as they cook along with her ... may you always be happy here.

Comments

Mary Bilyeu

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 9:17 p.m.

I love that this is a frivolous topic, and yet it touches a nerve! I love all of the dessert ideas -- brownies, cupcakes, pie, cheesecake ... sigh ... :) But I've gotta say, still, I'm a big fan of the cake; and people are still talking about not having cake, despite the bride having been GORGEOUS and everything having been stellar. It's expected. Should people revise their expectations??? That's what I'm trying to determine -- is this a trend or just a personal matter?

A2K

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 7:42 p.m.

The ostentatious, spend-spend-spend, "Look how much BETTER our wedding is than so-and-so's" and inviting people who you couldn't care less about, just to "get more money & loot" is disgusting...I feel the same way about a 2-3K cake that you are just trying to show-off with. It's vulgar and tasteless in more than one way. We had cupcakes for our wedding...moist cake, silky buttercream, tastefully decorated, and only cost $150 for 6 dozen. In fact, we only invited people we'd actually have over on a normal day/really liked - so we had 55 people total. It was magical and almost stress-free :O)

A2K

Wed, Mar 23, 2011 : 12:14 p.m.

Yes! That is very similar to what I've heard before as well (and also made me happy to decline both invitations as we didn't know the couple very well at all, and were wonder if we were on the "strategic loot" list). *sigh!*

Mary Bilyeu

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 9:21 p.m.

Hi -- I actually heard someone utter the words to me that they expected to have their wedding paid for in terms of the value of the gifts they received, and so strategically invited "key" people. I was appalled! It's a celebration of love and commitment, not a festival of greed! When I got married, I only invited family and the closest of friends; I'm with you -- it's about sharing your life with loved ones, those who are most important to you ....

Jennifer Schnepper

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 6:36 p.m.

I don't like cake, nor have I ever. Why would I want to spend over $1,000 on something that I do not like, nor would not eat? My wedding dress didn't even cost that much! I'm getting married in November and there will be no cake served at my wedding, aside from cheesecake. I would rather eat pie any day of the week. I understand that some wish to stick with the tradition, but if the bride and the groom cannot stand the taste of it, why should they serve it? If I have to pay for it, then I am going to pay for something that I will actually eat and enjoy. Take your over-frosted flowers and pass them off on someone else. As for me, bring on the wedding pie!

Bertha Venation

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 8:30 p.m.

Go'on, girl!! You on fire now! I'm with you!

Bertha Venation

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 5:28 p.m.

Innovative creativitiy would really be welcomed at my next wedding, as long as they play "Our Love Is Here To Stay." A must at all of my weddings! :)

Michael

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 5:27 p.m.

Thing is, Cake at weddings(and birthdays), as well as throwing rice (to imitate semen) is of pagan origins, and it seems fitting that you placed a Hebraic image at the beginning of the article to hint at the fact that the wedding was probably one of orthodox Hebrew peoples. It amazes me that people can be so quick to stick to the traditions of the gentiles, and when one breaks tradition they shun them to the depths. People need to stop being so hypocritical and either follow the religion they claim allegiance to, or stop reading the bible and follow the religion of society.

Mary Bilyeu

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 9:18 p.m.

Hi, Michael -- The stone at the beginning of the post was a gift from a very dear friend, and it's been in every post I've written for AnnArbor.com since I began contributing in July, 2009. In English, it means "You should always be happy," which is what I hope people will be when they get their weekly chance to visist with me ....

Sarah Rigg

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 1:30 p.m.

I've never been a big fan of cake, especially the store-bought ones with the dreadful thick, nasty frosting. I never understood why people vied for the piece with the most frosting and sugary flowers - it makes my skin crawl to think about it! At my wedding, we had our caterer make some plain spice cakes, and they were OK, but if I was doing it over again, I'd probably skip cake altogether. Give me a cheesecake or a piece of brownie any day over cake.

Bertha Venation

Tue, Mar 22, 2011 : 5:20 p.m.

I'm with you, Sarah. I'd much rather have some sort of other dessert that is really worth the calories!