You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Wed, Jan 20, 2010 : 11 a.m.

Questions in the aftermath of the Haitian earthquake

By Mona Shand

IMG_0832.JPG

Noah and Mark Shand, Dominican Republic 12-19-09

It's hard to believe, but one month ago today we were standing just a few hundred miles from Port-au-Prince, Haiti. We spent a blissful week vacationing in the Dominican Republic, enjoying sun, sand and surf at the beautiful Club Med Punta Cana. Now, much of the country has become a makeshift refugee camp. Dominican hospitals and hotels are packed to the brim with the injured from the disastrous earthquake in neighboring Haiti, and like so many, I find it hard to look away.

Any decent (and even not-so-decent) news reporter must quickly acquire the ability to separate his/herself from the story, as it's the only way to survive witnessing the countless tragedies the job entails. But sadly, I have found that separation often continues when I am not covering, but merely watching news unfold.

It's hard to admit, but in the immediate aftermath of the earthquake I found myself watching through somewhat callous news eyes. Instead of really "seeing" what was happening, I was focused on analyzing the coverage. "How many reporters are heading down there?" I wondered? Where were they staying? How hard was it to edit and feed back a story in those conditions?

And then I saw her.

I don't know her name or her age, or really anything about her. I only saw a glimpse as a camera panned across one of countless villages now reduced to rubble. She stood on top of what once was a roof, perhaps her own, her back to the camera. On her hip she held an infant, a baby covered in dust, wearing tattered clothes and sucking his thumb, his face poking out over her shoulder. Another child pulled at her hand- a toddler, perhaps 2 or 3 years old, kicking stones with his bare, dirty feet. It took that simple image: two young children doing what all children do, doing what MY children do, their mother holding them like all mothers do, holding them like I do, to jar me out of news reporter mode and back into humanity. The tears haven't stopped coming ever since.

The feelings of helplessness in the wake of such suffering can be paralyzing. My oldest child is just 2.5, far too young to understand what is happening in Haiti. In his little world, a "disaster" occurs when his Thomas the Tank Engine has disappeared (which is really not cause for concern in my little world). So before bedtime we just try to help him say a prayer for those who lost their homes ("But Mama, why can't they find them?") and those who are hurt ("Do they need a kiss to make it better?"). We will do what we can to support the relief effort through the Red Cross. Thursday night a local family originally from Haiti (you can hear the full story by clicking here) to support the George Stines Foundation, which operates medical and dental clinics in Haiti. For those with older children, ABC news has compiled this list of resources for talking to kids about the earthquake. But I have my own list of questions that don't seem to have any answers.

Why did this particular disaster have to happen on that particular island given the already near desperate conditions prior to the earthquake? At night when I close my eyes I see that woman holding her two children and can't help but wonder why, despite the threads of humanity that make us similar, our lives turned out so differently. How is it fair that I sit with my two kids in my too nice house full of too much stuff, a spectator to her suffering? What will happen to her and the rest of the people of Haiti when the news crews pack up and leave, off to chase the next breaking story? Will our hearts and wallets remain open once the headlines fade? What more can we do to help, and what should we have been doing before this even happened? All I can think of to do right now is to hold my babies a little closer, and give thanks the only trembling in our lives is that of my own hands.

Mona Shand is a radio and TV news reporter who lives in Brighton.

Comments

Mona Shand

Thu, Jan 21, 2010 : 3:34 p.m.

Thank you for your comment, and I certainly appreciate your insight. I apologize if you think I am giving out inaccurate information. I did not mention this in the article, but I am in fact a former employee of Club Med and lived in Punta Cana for some time. When I said "much of the country" I was in fact referring to Haiti, and not the Dominican Republic. I know for a fact that Dominican hospitals are packed with the injured, as my own cousin is currently working in one. I also know for a fact that some hotels have been used as makeshift hospitals- I have former colleagues who tell me the guests from their property were moved to another hotel owned by the same company so that the lower occupancy property could be used as a temporary hospital. In no way do I wish to dissuade anyone from traveling to the DR- I am sorry if you saw it that way. I have nothing but the fondest memories of my time working, living and vacationing there.

Ginnie Bedggood

Thu, Jan 21, 2010 : 3:14 p.m.

'What more can we do to help?' Ms. Shand asks. Well the first thing we can do is NOT put out erroneous information. 'We spent a blissful week vacationing in the Dominican Republic, enjoying sun, sand and surf at the beautiful Club Med Punta Cana. Now, much of the country has become a makeshift refugee camp.' This is NOT TRUE. I live in Puerto Plata, Dominican Republic & have done for more than 17 years and the DR does not in any way resemble a makeshift refugee camp. It IS true that the DR has opened its hospitals to injured Haitians and that the Dominican Republic has made a magnificent humanitarian response, sending mobile kitchens, water trucks and other supplies to Haiti. The tourist destinations in the DR are operating normally: as a matter of fact, Punta Cana didn't even feel the Haitian earthquake, although we did feel it in Puerto Plata. In the Dominican Republic there are no disease epidemics, no shortages of food (or booze!), no wandering bands of displced persons and most certainly NO REFUGEE CAMPS. It does a disservice to put out information which might encourage travellers to cancel their holiidays to the Dominican Republic. If this happened in large numbers Dominicans would lose their jobs. There is absolutely NO NEED to cancel DR holidays. Supporting the Dominican economy means more help can be sent to Haiti.