You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 10:42 a.m.

Watching the Egyptian crisis unfold: A personal perspective

By Mona Shand

Mona_Egypt.jpg

Giza, Egypt 2004 | Photo by Mona Shand

No I don't live in a pyramid, and no I don't have a pet camel.

These were the answers I sometimes wished I could tatoo on my forehead as a child, given the inevitable barrage of silly questions that came every time I told someone my parents were from Egypt. Sure, it was cool to bring in papyrus drawings and little alabaster sphinxes for show-and-tell, but for most of my childhood being Egyptian felt like an annoyance bordering on a burden. I secretly wished my parents were from the upper Midwest and not upper Egypt. I didn't want to be "exotic" or "foreign." I didn't want to be different.

Most days, I didn't feel very Egyptian until my parents came home. While at school or playing with friends, I could convince myself I was just as American as they were. Sure, I didn't have that nice, shiny, straight hair, but I had Cabbage Patch dolls and ate Twinkies just like everyone else.

Sundays, however, were a different story. We went to our Egyptian church for our hours (yes, plural!) long mass, then Sunday School, then out to lunch with our Egyptian friends, followed by an Egyptian dinner with our Egyptian family. I was torn between embracing the familiar sounds, smells and tastes of that world and craving the other. It was baklava vs. Barbies and the winner was unclear.

My mom was a university professor and because she had summers off we spent many of them in Egypt, with my brother and I complaining and whining for most of the 10+ hour trip over. In our petulant tween and teenage years, we were simply not able to appreciate what an amazing opportunity it was. We wanted to swim in our backyard pool, not in the Red Sea. We preferred modern wonders (like Pong on the Atari) over ancient ruins. We just wanted to be like all of our friends. We just wanted to be "normal."

Somewhere between college and grad school I finally came to the conclusion that hailing from Egypt was actually kind of cool. I was fortunate enough to live and work in Europe for a time and took advantage of the proximity to visit the motherland on my own on several occasions. But it was still just that, my mother's (and father's) land. Not mine.

I guess it ultimately took 37 years and an international geopolitical crisis for me to fully embrace Egypt as a piece of myself. As the protests began last week, I found myself simultaneously unable to turn away and yet scared to watch. As I sit on my comfortable couch in my comfortable house watching the unrest (I love that word, it makes it sound like just a bad night's sleep) unfold, it occurs to me that one decision on the part of my parents, one lucky move is all that separates me from the desperate, frustrated masses. With eyes that look just like mine, they are crying for what I have been fortunate enough to enjoy my entire life. I fear for my family there, for their safety, for their very survival, for the survival of the entire country. Will I ever be able to take my children there? Will my parents ever return to the place they loved enough to leave? It comes down to this — if Egypt is in crisis, then so am I.

One member of my family in Cairo says he'll never leave. He says this is the moment to fight for his country, to fight for what he deserves. And he's right — I just can't wrap my brain around why I never had to fight. There but for the grace of God.

Egypt's next chapter is being written before our eyes. I hope that when we look back on this period, it will one day be the country's proudest hour. Until then, all I can do is pray in words from the Bible that have never made more sense: "Blessed be Egypt, MY people."

Mona Shand is a radio and TV news reporter and the child of Egyptian immigrants. You can read more on her blog.

Comments

ContreMilice

Fri, Feb 4, 2011 : 8:25 p.m.

Mona, thank you for a very sensitive article. I think your experiences growing up as a first generation American of immigrant parents is something that resonates with many other children of immigrants. I share the concerns of all here who fear that the current upheaval in Egypt could lead to a reprise of Iran in 1979. I fervently hope that the "new" Egypt will be a strong _secular_ democracy that respects the rights of members of all faiths _equally_ especially minorities such as Coptic Christians and will continue to uphold peace in the neighborhood such as reiterating and reinforcing the historic, groundbreaking peace treaty with Israel that has held for over three decades now. That extremists like the Muslim Brotherhood, the role model for terrorist Hamas, could take over in Egypt and Jordan (where demonstrations are also taking place under the radar of the Western media's gaze) is really an alarming possibility for all peace-loving and tolerant peoples whether in Egypt, North and Sub-Saharan Africa, the Western Hemisphere, Europe, Asia, and across the Pacific Rim. May it never come to pass; we've seen the disaster in Iran and how its venomous Sharia-tinged thug government violently suppresses even the hint of a mass uprising against that autocratic, aggressive, theocratic, antisemitic, bigoted regime. —ContreMilice

demistify

Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 4:45 p.m.

The Week in Review section of the NY Times printed a cartoon that excellently summed up the situation: "How thrilling! A popular uprising in a Muslim country unseating a despot! What could possibly go wrong?". The setting is given as "US Embassy, Iran, 1979"

bedrog

Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 3:58 p.m.

The Egyptian demonstrations are united in only what they are against: i.e. Mubarak. What they are 'for' is diverse and often contradictory: And yes, "Islamists" , like the Muslim Brotherhood and the 'salafis' to the right of them ( worldwide including Al Qaeda, the Taliban, al Shabaab etc) , are aggressive extremists, which not all "islamics"...more properly ' Muslims.'. are, although many of the latter are often seem rather passive ( or quietly sympathetic) toward the former . This gives 'Islamists' the capacity to set agendas ( while often wreaking havoc on the very more moderate folks who tolerate them). IF "Islamists' come to power in Egypt , Mubarak will look increasingly great in the rearview mirror, to both Egyptians and the world. Obama has been right in not jumping onto a bandwagon headed who knows where? It's worth noting that the ideological grandpa of todays Islamist jihiadists was Egyptian Syed Qutb of the Muslim Brotherhood..and one of his spawn is Egyptian Ayman al zawahiri, al Qaeda's #2 and the assassin of Mubarak's predecessor.

Heidi Hess Saxton

Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 2:49 p.m.

Monica: Thank you for sharing such a poignant glimpse into your life. (I didn't know baklava was Egyptian!) Though it is undoubtedly painful to watch at present, being able to live with a foot in both cultures is such a gift. I hope your own children will come to see this as well. I've heard some express concern over what will happen to the Coptic Christians (what is ALREADY happening to Christians: <a href="http://www.christianpost.com/article/20110111/christian-man-killed-in-egypt-shooting-5-wounded/)" rel='nofollow'>http://www.christianpost.com/article/20110111/christian-man-killed-in-egypt-shooting-5-wounded/)</a> if another government takes over. What do you think would be a best-case scenario for the days ahead? What kind of leader do you think the people of Egypt needs now?

ContreMilice

Fri, Feb 4, 2011 : 8:23 p.m.

Heidi, although baklava is a popular dessert across the Mediterranean world and particularly in Greece, Turkey, and throughout the Middle East and North Africa as well as increasingly in the rest of the world where it has migrated, it is not a typically indigenous Egyptian treat. Although the origin is not known with 100% percent certainty, it is likely of a Turkic—possibly nomadic—provenance. According to the _Oxford Companion to Food_ (Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 2nd edition, ©2006), p. 300, "…the earliest form of baklava" was an outcome of "Turkish nomads adapting their concept of layered bread developed in the absence of ovens to the use of the oven and combining it with the usual Persian pastry filling of nuts. "If this is so, baklava actually pre-dated filo [layers of dough also of Turkish origin—although the word _filo_ itself is from Greek—and used in Greek spanakopita and pastries such as Central European strudel] and the paper-thin pastry we know today was probably an innovation of the Ottoman sultan's kitchens at Topkapi palace in Istanbul…" One thing we can almost all agree upon, though, is that it sure is tasty! Let there be good food, conviviality, understanding, and peaceful exchanges of culture between various ethnic groups across the globe, and may a secular, tolerant, free, open, and democratic Egypt be in our near future and not a Sunni version of the nightmarish Iranian Shi'a mullahcracy!

Mona Shand

Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 6:38 p.m.

Heidi, thanks so much for the kind words. Copts are certainly concerned about who and what will come next for Egypt. The rise in violence against us in Egypt has come at the same time as the rise of extremist groups within the country. The idea of Egypt not being a secular nation is unbearable- I pray we never see that day, as I think the consequences would be felt throughout the entire Middle East and world. Obviously, the situation has taken a turn for the worse today. What we need in the immediate is for somehow, someway the protestors to realize that many of their demands have in fact been addressed. I know they want Mubarak to step down immediately, but I fear that would only lead to a vacuum of power and even more chaos than we're already seeing.

Heidi Hess Saxton

Wed, Feb 2, 2011 : 3:27 p.m.

I found this article at USA Today that offers one perspective, distinguishing between &quot;Islamic&quot; and &quot;Islamist.&quot; Do you think this is a fair representation? <a href="http://content.usatoday.com/communities/Religion/post/2011/01/egypt-protests-muslim-brotherhood-mubarak/1" rel='nofollow'>http://content.usatoday.com/communities/Religion/post/2011/01/egypt-protests-muslim-brotherhood-mubarak/1</a>