You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Wed, Sep 21, 2011 : 10:48 a.m.

'Biggest Loser' starts new season with Ann Arbor contestant

By Ann Dwyer

090411_LOUNDS.jpg

Debbie Lounds

NOTE: Contains spoiler info.

A new season of “The Biggest Loser” began on NBC last night and with it came a shiny new gym, shiny new trainers, shiny new stakes and a shiny new premise. But first, it started in a dusty old desert.

If you’re not familiar with “The Biggest Loser,” it’s a competition reality show in which obese contestants compete to lose weight and win big money. And this season, Ann Arbor’s own Debbie Lounds is competing in it.

In last night's season premiere, the 15 contestants were loaded into a van and were left in the middle of a desert near Death Valley. While they questioned whether or not they should be worried, a large Humvee drove up and delivered host Alison Sweeney. Thankfully, she arrived to dispel the mystery of why they had numbers on their shirts. I’m hoping she did this for our benefit and that contestants didn’t really think it was a nifty coincidence.

But it was all part of the shiny new premise: The contestants are teamed up by age grou. Three groups, including the 50-plus group that, at 60 years old, Debbie was placed in.

There was more new stuff: They were not just playing for $100,000, they were now playing for $250,000!

And even if a contestant were eliminated, they would get a second chance. At the end of the season, each contestant would compete in marathon, all 26.2 miles, ending in the same desert where they were standing.

But wait! There’s more! More trainers, that is. Stepping in for Jillian Michaels, who is apparently making enough money on her own endeavors that she no longer has to harangue overweight people in person, are two new trainers, including tennis pro Anna Kournikova.

Thankfully, our military wasn’t too busy to deliver the trainers via CH-46 helicopter.

We got our first wheezy glimpse of just how out of shape the contestants are when they were forced to run (mainly walk) one mile in a group. The prize for the groups who crossed first was their choice of trainer. Surprisingly, almost everyone wanted mainstay Bob Harper, except for young Ramon, who said he wouldn’t mind be trained by the blonde Kournikova.

Unfortunately, as would be the case throughout the two-hour premiere, things did not go well for the older group, who turtled their way to the finish line. And while this didn’t have anywhere near the same result as the old fable, it did provide a TV-friendly moment of music-swelling inspiration when Kournikova ran out to help her team get to the finish line. She was quickly followed by the other contestants, which led to talk about how even though it was competition, they were all there to support one another.

The middle agers won the race and went with Bob Harper. The younger group chose Dolvett Quince, leaving the older group with Kournikova.

As is par for the course, the next day the contestants were put through a grueling workout in which the trainers acted ridiculously cruel to prove that they mean business. This worked well for professional trainer Quince, who came off as a drill instructor. But Kournikova came off as trying too hard. And I couldn’t help but feel that when Kournikova denied Debbie water during the workout, that maybe she shouldn’t be a trainer.

In the end, the older group had lost the least amount of weight and were forced to vote a member off their team. As they sat together to discuss who would go, a strange thing happened.

It seemed like Debbie set herself up to get kicked off. First, she told another member of her team, a woman who had lost her home to Hurricane Katrina and her husband to cancer, that her crying was “annoying.”

She then said the magic words: “I’m not saying I want to go home, but...” and then went on to say that she had a lot of support back home.

Nothing will get you kicked off a reality show faster than talking about how you don’t need to be there. Maybe Debbie didn’t realize this; maybe she really didn’t want to be there. Who knows. But she was dismissed, and she looked very happy in the footage of her back home.

But another question remains in the wake of the premiere: Is it fair to make older contestants compete like this against people less than half their age? Sure, it’s brought up a couple of times during the show that older contestants have come on and “burnt the house down.” But really, the weight lost by the two younger groups was significantly higher than that of the older group.

It’s called a metabolism, and it slows down with age. Couldn’t this, and other factors, contribute to a very unfair advantage? I’m a fitness nut, not a scientist, so please feel free to correct me in the comments.

Comments

BGSU_FALCON

Fri, Sep 23, 2011 : 3:19 p.m.

This reminds me of the Seinfeld episode in which George told Jerry to use better judgment when the latter told Kramer about George/Elaine's trip to the flea market. "Judgment Jerry. Use better judgment!" Which brings me to Debbie.... I don't know why she 1) criticize the other contestant and 2) say she has the support system at home. If she had the support at home, she wouldn't need to appear on the BL. It's a shame that she didn't think before she spoke because she could have stayed at least another week. Plus, this was a great opportunity that many people struggle to get. Hopefully she's losing the weight.

Heady99

Thu, Sep 22, 2011 : 4:02 p.m.

Maybe Debbie shouldn't have been so rude to the other contestant! There are people that are seriously over weight and need a program like this to save their life and she just threw her chance away. I do miss Jillian and I don't think Anna, although incredibly beautiful and talented, will be a good fit for Biggest Loser! I remain a fan for life and have lost over 50 pounds on my own using tips from this show!

KathrynHahn

Thu, Sep 22, 2011 : 8:28 a.m.

Jillian Michaels was great on this show, now it seems as though her ego could lose a few pounds..... not much of a fan of hers anymore. As for Debbie, this show is so hard to get on, I tried for years, so I'm disappointed. I ended up losing over 100 lbs on my own, hope her "support group" at home helps her too.

Michelle09

Thu, Sep 22, 2011 : 5:10 a.m.

I definitely felt like Debbie quit. You NEVER give the rest of your team motive to vote you off whether you believe you have a support system at home or not. Not to mention, there's no way that your home support system will compare to the controlled environment that you are in at the ranch. I just think the 1st week got the best of her. However, if she watches the show, she would have remembered that all contestants from previous seasons struggled through their first workouts. I was really excited to see someone from the area on this show, but now it seems that her spot should have went to someone else who truly needs and wants to be there. I hope she does do well at home though and makes it back to complete the marathon. SN: I'm not really feeling Anna Kournikova as a trainer. Being an athlete does not necessarily give you the credentials to help others on their weight loss journey. Hopefully her techniques get better throughout the season, because seeing Bonnie only lose 4 lbs in the 1st episode was kind of disappointing. Contestants usually shed the most lbs those first couple of weeks since they are losing mostly water weight. Anyway, love this show, and I agree and I cant wait for the next episode!

BGSU_FALCON

Fri, Sep 23, 2011 : 3:26 p.m.

I don't know how much running the contestants will do, but I will guess that at least two people from the "older" group will struggle completing a marathon (assuming there is no time limit). Regarding Anna, she was added to the show to get more men to watch it. That's a shame because, as you noted, being an athlete isn't the same as being a fitness trainer. Like I did when Kim Lyons came to BL when Jillian left, I'll give Anna the benefit of the doubt and see how the season plays out, but the women on her team should have had higher numbers for the first week. Week 2 is where many contestants struggle.