You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 12:16 p.m.

Muslims celebrate Eid al-Fitr with mixed emotions

By Ahmed Chaudhry

The Islamic month of fasting, as grueling as it may seem, has always been a period of satisfaction and disciplinary achievement for Muslims. There is always a feeling in the air around sunset when the fast is broken that is decidedly different than normal dinners during the rest of the year. There is that common sense of accomplishment having made it through the day and that familiar buzz as the days remaining wind down towards Eid al-Fitr, a holiday as joyous for Muslims as Christmas for Christians or Hanukkah for Jews.

However, this Ramadan has had a distinctly different feeling to it for many American Muslims than ones prior. In past years, it was not uncommon for me to get questions asking me why I was fasting immediately followed by more questions about what Islam was all about. This year, it not only seemed that everyone knew what Islam was, but many non-Muslims also had predetermined opinions of the faith.

eid prayer.jpg

Muslims perform Eid prayers in Ann Arbor.

Photo courtesy of Saad Chaudhry

Like many Muslims I've talked to at the end of the holy month, along with eating and drinking from sunrise to sunset, I wish I had also given up watching television for Ramadan (specifically the news networks). Theatrics ranged from a debate about the right to build mosques in New York, Tennessee, Wisconsin and other locations to an attention-hungry pastor with an epic mustache in Florida crying wolf to Muslims about a mass burning of their holy book to look forward to at the end of the month. It was truly hard for Muslims to fast in peace; an added test of willpower, that is.

One of the reasons for this change in mood towards Muslims in America could be the unfortunate and completely coincidental lapse of the lunar calendar leaving the holiday of Eid dangerously close to Sept. 11. Another reason may be the growing Islamaphobia in this country. And yet another explanation is that none of what is happening is actually is grim as it seems; that is, Islamaphobia is not as large of an issue as is perceived by most people in America. This last one seem to be the most optimistic explanation. Hopefully, Islamaphobia is not a true problem in the U.S., and the mass media has blown it out of proportion like it does everything else.

I see several parallels, in fact, to several previous episodes of headlines we've encountered. Only a few weeks ago, the country was captivated by an oil spill that couldn't be stopped and was given everything from catchy names for solutions like "top kill" and "top hat" to a live oil spill camera feed on our TV screens almost 24/7. Just a few months earlier, everyone's attention was on the"balloon boy" who turned out to be hiding in his garage the whole time because his attention seeking father (no better than Terry Jones) wanted his own reality show. It's safe to say that our media networks and unfortunately many Americans operate on a "flavor of the week" news story system.

A safe (or perhaps naïve) prediction is that nobody will be talking about these things in a few weeks or months time. We've stopped talking about many past stories, but it's not as though the flooding in Pakistan has stopped or the oil spill has been all cleaned up or even that the poor region in our very own country has even remotely recovered from a hurricane that swept through five years ago. Certainly the politicians will have found these topics less important to discuss after the midterm elections are over with.

It is important for Muslims to remember that the point of Ramadan is to teach them about patience, humility and spirituality. Certainly, all of them have been tested this month, but to react in any irregular (especially violent) way would only make things worse for the world and deprive them of celebration that is owed to everybody at the end of an always arduous month.

I have participated in interfaith work now for years from my introduction by Rev. Dan McQuown, the chaplain at Albion College to my current place with the Interfaith Round Table of Washtenaw County. Interfaith dialogue has finally been thrust into the national spotlight. We stand on the doorstep of great opportunities for interfaith work but must remember to leave it to be led by the people that have been working in it for years like The Interfaith Round Table and The Interfaith Council for Peace & Justice as is evidenced by their thorough and methodical consideration of the subject. We can't allow "overnight experts" to come inexplicably out of the woodwork and sabotage this moment. Recent events just lend proof to the notion that interfaith dialogue is an unavoidable subject; nor should it be avoided in order for people to coexist peacefully.

Ahmed Chaudhry was born in Lahore, Pakistan and moved to the Michigan in 1994. As a recent graduate of Albion College, where he received a degree in biology and religious studies, he plans to pursue a career in public health.



Mon, Sep 13, 2010 : 12:43 p.m.

Ahmed, I'm glad to see that your interfaith beginnings at a historically Methodist school have continued into your adult life. It speaks highly of both you and the educators and leadership at the institution that they were able to help instill such a base that you are still following this passion today. I too graduated from a religious school and continue to work on interfaith partnerships in the Ann Arbor area. I'm happy to see a young Muslim man like yourself so involved in such important work. Keep it up!

Macabre Sunset

Mon, Sep 13, 2010 : 12:38 a.m.

Tom, First off, there's a lot of anti-Semitic bigotry being whipped up lately. But that's another story. I think it's just more accepted as the norm around the world so we're immune to it. As for the Founding Fathers? You have to realize this was more than 200 years ago. The term "Natural God" indicated something they did not understand. Science addressed far fewer questions. What was clear from some writings (Madison, Jefferson in particular) was a lack of patience for religion. The separation of church and state is what made this country possible. The right to worship whatever you want... and the right not to. They felt the latter freedom was just as important.

Tom Lienert

Sun, Sep 12, 2010 : 12:43 p.m.

In response to "Macabre Sunset", the Founding Fathers you referred to were not necessarily atheists. Many were "Deists", meaning they believed in God, but didn't subscribe to a specific organized religion.


Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 6:34 p.m.

@homeland conspiracy: How do you suggest moderate Muslims "find the bad apple & throw it away" using "more than just lip service"? Are you suggesting moderate Muslims become militant? Hopefully not, that would defeat the purpose. You have to offer a real solution. Unfortunately, the world situation can't be solved as easily as finding a bad apple and simply throwing it away.

Macabre Sunset

Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 6:33 p.m.

I volunteer to represent those of the atheist lack-of-faith. I celebrated today by watching Michigan defeat Notre Dame, 28-24. We're near the beginning of a rather arduous three months of unprayer, leading into our holiest day, which falls on November 27 this year. We need to keep our focus, though, because Atheistophobia remains somewhat active in America. Like the Muslims, we have not had an atheist president in recent memory, though one can argue many of our Founding Fathers had no patience for organized religion. After our holiest day, we plan to celebrate by pretty much not doing anything mean to anyone. Like always. We stay out of the headlines that way. True, there are some militant atheists like the guy who sued the school in California over the Pledge of Allegiance. We appreciate his spirit, but wonder if it's the right time for that kind of protest as it really upsets some religious folks. But we remain entirely non-violent. All of us. So people mostly leave us alone.

Urban Sombrero

Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 5:44 p.m.

Where are the atheist/agnostic contributors? So far, I've seen articles by a Catholic, and a Muslim. Just wondering if all belief systems will eventually be covered.

Tom Lienert

Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 3:29 p.m.

Well DUH! Maybe it's because there isn't a lot of glaringly obvious anti-Semitic or anti-Catholic bigotry being whipped up this month.

Homeland Conspiracy

Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 3:27 p.m.

Many people wouldn't have Islamaphobia if the more moderate Muslims would do something to stop your Militant Muslims from killing anyone or anything that doesn't agree with them. And I mean doing something more than lip service.Blaming your average Joe for being afraid of all Muslims is not useful. It's time for the moderate & peaceful Muslims to clean up their side of the street. Take out the trash, Pull the weeds from your garden, find the bad apple & throw it away. But this is just my opinion.


Sat, Sep 11, 2010 : 3:07 p.m.

What is the point of this article? Why do we make special news concessions for anybody outside the Christian faith? I dont see you posting stories about how Catholics or the Jewish spend their time.