You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Mon, Aug 5, 2013 : 11:35 a.m.

Losing my religion: Are non-religious people bad for America?

By Wayne Baker

Saints-Angels-Deities-glowing-in-REM-Losing-My-Religion-video.jpg

Deities, angels and saints aglow! These luminous images of godlike figures appear in R.E.M.’s video for ‘Losing My Religion.’ (See the video below.)

From Dr. Wayne Baker: Welcome back Terry Gallagher, who last week wrote about values associated with exchanging favors. Here is Terry’s first column in a new series.

Even though Losing My Religion became R.E.M.’s greatest global hit—the fact is that religion and religious affiliation remain strong in most parts around the world.

So, what do we make of the “Nones”—America’s most rapidly growing “religious” group? These are people who respond to pollsters’ standard questions about religious affiliation with the option: “None.” These millions of men and women now comprise nearly 20 percent of the U.S. population and a third of adults under age 30, according to reports from the Pew Research Center.

But the story isn’t as simple as a rejection of religion. In December, Wayne Baker explored this trend in an OurValues column and concluded: “Within this broad category, some people do have spiritual and religious beliefs—they just don’t identify with any specific religious group.”

Certainly, there are plenty of good reasons for thoughtful people to reject traditional religions and their constraints. To be clear, most of the Nones do not consider themselves atheists. In fact, many Nones have rich spiritual lives.

Care to meet someone who is a spiritual counselor to these folks? Tom Stella is the featured author interview this week in the main pages of Read The Spirit. Stella argues that we should welcome them and their points of view, even if they differ sharply from traditional religious beliefs.

The first question I hope you’ll consider this week in Our Values is this: Why are so many of us worried about these men and women? In some interesting new data from the Pew Research Center, nearly half of Americans—48 percent—say the growing number of “people who are not religious” is bad for American society.

While 11 percent say the trend is good for the country, 39 percent say that it doesn’t make much difference. Overall, then, we’re evenly split on whether to worry about our neighbors who have chosen not to make religious affiliation a part of their lives.

But, you’ve got to wonder: Why do these men and women make half of the population so nervous?

How about you?

Does it matter that traditional religious affiliation is declining?

Is it bad for the country? Or doesn’t it matter?

R.E.M.: Losing My Religion

Here is the entire song from the band R.E.M. Released in 1991, the song still ranks as the band’s highest-charting single. In interviews after the song’s release, singer and lyricist Michael Stipe explained the meaning in various ways: Once, he said it was a metaphor for losing one’s temper; more often, he said it was about romantic obsession with a loved one. But as this music video shows, the song has evolved into an anthem for spiritual seekers.

Comments

NSider

Wed, Aug 7, 2013 : 4:45 p.m.

Was it Karl Marx who stated "Religion is the opiate for the masses"? Whoever said it, I agree with them. I hold several D. degrees myself, Dr. Baker, and am disturbed by two main concepts whenever someone says the word "religion". #1 - if you don't follow a certain ritual, you aren't religious. Okay, I can sort of accept that, but let us not forget that Wiccans have their rituals too. #2 - there is always some person at the head of a religions saying "I am closer to god, I know more than you, so send me your money". Wrong. I suggest that more study be made into the earlier "religions", many of them will tell you, we are all equally close to god, but you must define what god means to you. Even buddha said as much when he said every man must find his own path. Does it matter that "traditional religious affiliation is declining?" you ask. No, I see it as the best of signs; perhaps humanity has finally evolved beyond being the masses that need opiates, perhaps individuals are asking their own questions and finding their own answers, and NOT relying on someone else to tell us where the path is.

Greg

Tue, Aug 6, 2013 : 1:32 p.m.

Couple of points. Considering religion has done serious damage to others, at least as much as it has done good, why would we want to it??? Crusades, Catholic church for decades if not centuries supporting child molestors, religious groups killing, maiming and more on those different from their own group. Also, firmly believe the old saying as have seen major evidence with my own eyes that it is true. The Moral Majority Is Neither.

DBH

Mon, Aug 5, 2013 : 5:06 p.m.

I think this headline falls under the category of "troll."