New University of Michigan North Quad dorm stirs emotions, analyses
Corner of State and Huron streets in late June 2010
Dwight Lang | Contributor
North Quad sign on State Street
Dwight Lang | Contributor
Work scene along State Street
Dwight Lang | Contributor
Looking down I saw a man wearing a hard hat and work clothes - perhaps in his early 40’s - crossing the street toward me. I remembered my dad coming home after laying pipe in home construction for more than 30 years in Sacramento, Calif. Their hands were dirty.
We sized one another up for a few moments before I broke the silence. “Ya know - standing here at street level you can see just how big these buildings are. They really sort of look like palaces. The view must be great from the top floor.” Without skipping a beat he looked straight in my eyes: “Yeah, they’re for a bunch of rich college students.” I winced.
Near State and East Washington
Dwight Lang | Contributor
In an instant the light turned green and we quickly started walking across Huron Street. I wanted to say something. It was as if this man was channeling my dead father’s mistrust of anyone with a college degree. After a couple seconds I reacted to my street crossing colleague: “I’ve always thought workers on various construction sites around campus should get reduced tuition for their children who might attend the University of Michigan someday.”
As we turned to walk in opposite directions he calmly reacted: “Yeah, good luck with that idea when you run it by your university president.”
Corner of State and East Washington
Dwight Lang | Contributor
Perhaps he was in a hurry to grab a quick lunch. Maybe he was annoyed with my comments or what he assumed I do for a living. I will never know. But recently I have been wondering about his work routines in the final construction of suite-style living quarters and classrooms he probably considers a bit extravagant. What are his thoughts as he gazes down at this university town?
West Side of North Quad/Late June 2010
Dwight Lang | Contributor
As we parted ways I was taken aback. My day had started on an upbeat note. I would have a pleasant lunch with colleagues and we would probably talk about our classes. Instead this chance meeting highlighted topics of a course I teach: The Experience of Social Class in College and the Community. Rather than a friendly exchange about a new building’s progress and appearance, I encountered social class tensions that swirl around us everyday - even at the university. Perhaps I should say especially at a university where social class is in the making.
Huron Street side of North Quad
Dwight Lang | Contributor
But that day on a Midwestern college campus - like so many other campuses where men and women work with their bodies and minds to build and teach - social class suddenly appeared. It surfaced where economic differences can be invisible or avoided and too often abstractly discussed while reviewing inequality statistics or reading texts on justice and the right thing to do.
The following week I shared this encounter with my students as a way to illustrate how social class is experienced at the University of Michigan. Many expressed uneasiness hearing and talking about how others - from different social places - view them as wealthy and privileged. Others who had self-identified as first in their families to attend college seemed to appreciate my street crossing partner’s aggravation. We explored understandable resentments associated with class difference and use of the word “rich” during the current too-big-to-fail economic recovery.
Our late semester conversations clarified how social diversity surrounds us in unpredictable ways, even as we admire state-of-the-art campus buildings. Hopefully my brief meeting with a man I will probably never talk to again shows the usefulness of stepping outside taken for granted worlds.
Dwight Lang is a lecturer in the Department of Sociology at the University of Michigan and a contributor to AnnArbor.com.Â
Comments
Concerned Citizen
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 7:41 p.m.
Their children?,hmmm, how about an opportunity for the construction workers themselves?... Perhaps the Office of Continuing Education of BOTH Men & Women.
Jay Thomas
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 4:08 p.m.
After a couple seconds I reacted to my street crossing colleague: Ive always thought workers on various construction sites around campus should get reduced tuition for their children who might attend the University of Michigan someday. Why, aren't they being paid appropriately in the first place? We don't need more preferences; we have enough as it is. They all come at someone's expense.
ScottyBoy
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 2:26 p.m.
State of the art? How about parking for all those wealthy students with BMW's?
Lokalisierung
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 1:52 p.m.
"While it is a handsome building, I think only wealthy students are going to be able to live there." Do different dorms cost different amounts of money? (They didn't when I went to school (of course not here and a long time ago)
katznjammer
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 1:45 p.m.
I can understand how this workman might feel. While it is a handsome building, I think only wealthy students are going to be able to live there. It's probably full of amenities we couldn't imagine of when we were in college. I'm also holding my breath for what this new dorm, the new Zaragon Place II, CVS and (ACK!!) 7-ll will do to the State Street area. With U of M buying up more and more land (and paying no city taxes), pretty soon there won't be a downtown to speak of, just a big student area with college-age chain stores and fast-food places.
Lokalisierung
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 11:58 a.m.
Will it actually increase student housing? I thought I remember hearing when they first started this, that after it was completeed and operational, they weree going to completely redo anotehr Quad building so it would kind of even out?
Vivienne Armentrout
Tue, Jul 13, 2010 : 9:04 a.m.
Excellent essay. Thank you. I hope that there will be a news story that includes information about the cost to live in this new building. But I'm glad that the UM took upon itself the responsibility to build more student housing.