You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Tue, May 11, 2010 : 6:03 a.m.

Alma Wheeler Smith: The governor candidate Michigan won't get to vote for this year

By Ryan J. Stanton

Alma_Wheeler_Smith_campaign_4.jpg

State Rep. Alma Wheeler Smith interacts with a college student from Ann Arbor while on the campaign trail last month. At the end of their interaction, the student let Smith slap one of her campaign stickers over the Virg Bernero sticker he was wearing.

Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com

Editor's note: AnnArbor.com reporter Ryan J. Stanton shadowed Alma Wheeler Smith last month intending to write an in-depth story on her bid for governor. Smith's decision on Monday to drop out of the race changed plans to write that story, but here's a brief look at the abandoned campaign of a candidate who some say had the most credentials for the job.

Cutting her way through a shoulder-to-shoulder crowd inside Cobo Hall on her way to a podium to speak, Alma Wheeler Smith stopped for a moment to razz two college students wearing campaign stickers supporting one of her opponents.

Both students politely told Smith she'd have to earn their votes. The truth was, they weren't yet familiar with the veteran lawmaker's campaign to become Michigan's next governor, and so far they liked Lansing Mayor Virg Bernero.

Ten minutes and one standing ovation later, both students were letting Smith slap her campaign stickers over the top of Bernero's stickers, saying they liked her views on education.

Alma_Wheeler_Smith_campaign_3.jpg

Smith talks to two college students while campaigning last month. They said they appreciated her views on education.

Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com

"We're going to keep turning this crowd," Smith said with confidence, marching away as if what had transpired was no rare occurrence.

"It happens all the time," whispered Roderick Casey, a campaign volunteer and retired janitor from Ypsilanti who campaigned for Smith that day in Detroit.

That was last month when Smith's grassroots campaign was gaining momentum. Many who heard her message about turning around Michigan were being swayed, and Smith was on her way to getting 15,000 signatures to appear on the Aug. 3 primary ballot.

But the 68-year-old state representative from Washtenaw County's Salem Township announced on Monday her decision to abandon her bid for governor, citing a concern of splitting the progressive vote and ending up with a candidate who doesn't represent core Democratic values.

"Democrats need to unify behind a candidate, and I have come to believe that my continued candidacy would only serve to divide us further,” Smith said.

Smith was the underdog in the race for months. She faced formidable opponents in Bernero and House Speaker Andy Dillon. Her campaign hadn't attracted nearly as much hype or financial support.

Political pundits say Bernero is most likely to benefit from Smith's decision to drop out of the race. Like Smith, he is seen as a progressive, left-leaning candidate. Dillon at times has alienated key Democratic constituencies.

"Alma Wheeler Smith is the kind of fighter we need involved in our effort to shake things up in state government and to get our priorities straight in this time of crisis," Bernero said in a statement released Monday, adding Democrats should be proud of Smith for the gubernatorial campaign she ran.

Looking back on the campaign

"People say Alma Wheeler Smith is the best-qualified candidate for governor but she can't win," Smith told a crowd last month. "I can win. My campaign is the only campaign at this moment that is going up in the polls, and I will continue to climb in the polls because we are doing that grassroots activity that gets us forward."

Smith struggled to generate support for her candidacy, though. She amassed a mere $36,245 by the time she filed campaign finance statements in January — far from the level of money needed to run a successful gubernatorial campaign. And a welcome video on her campaign website up since November still has been viewed by less than 300 people.

Alma_Wheeler_Smith_campaign_2.jpg

Smith works the halls of Cobo Hall while campaigning in Detroit last month.

Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com

Yet Smith remained confident last month at the Democratic Endorsement Convention inside Cobo Hall, convinced her grassroots push for the top seat in state government was going strong enough to continue.

"The polls show that our momentum is growing well — that the others are kind of plateaued —and I intend to keep moving forward," she said. "We are working at raising money, always raising money. Unfortunately, until we do campaign finance reform, it is going to be about who gets the bucks."

Smith, who comes from a politically active family, has been well-known in and around Washtenaw County for many years. The daughter of a former Ann Arbor mayor, she rose up through the ranks. She began her political career in the trenches of Democratic campaigns and honed her skills as a cable commissioner, school board trustee and Washtenaw County commissioner.

"I've been on a school board for eight years, so I understand education and the demands that the teachers and the administrators face to deliver a quality education that makes sure that our kids are ready for college," Smith told a crowd last month.

"I have a program, Michigan Future, that will make certain that we have a preschool program for our 4-year-olds, so that they are ready for a school when they start in kindergarten. And we bookend that program with free tuition at our vocational technical schools, at our community colleges and at our four-year universities — our public universities — so that kids don't leave college with a debt of $30,000 and $40,000. That is no way to begin your next life."

Smith currently serves Michigan's 54th House District, but has 14 years of experience in the Legislature, including her years as a state senator.

"I bring great credentials in terms of issues and where I have stood, and as a member of appropriations, I have stood with you," she told a crowd of veterans last month. "And I will be the first one to tell you that if we are going to address the issues of veterans, if we're going to address education and jobs here in the state of Michigan, we need to be talking about revenue. We are not going to turn this state around unless the state of Michigan has dollars to invest in our people."

Smith took a bold stance during her campaign by openly calling for a massive state tax overhaul to raise $6.5 billion, which she argued could be used to restore funding for public schools, local police and fire protection, and important services such as mental health care.

"We need revenue in Michigan, and you're going to hear that coming out of my mouth," Smith said. "We need to tax the wealth of the state of Michigan, not the poor people of the state of Michigan, because we have a tremendous capacity under the Headlee limit to raise the dollars that will let us create public jobs and opportunities for people to go back to work quickly."

In 2001, Smith became the first black candidate to mount a campaign for governor on Michigan's Democratic ticket. She delayed those plans when she joined former Congressman David Bonior's campaign for governor as his choice for lieutenant governor.

Smith says being black has shaped her views and values. Born in 1941 in the era of Jim Crow segregation in Columbia, South Carolina, Smith said she confronted racial issues early on in her life.

She had a twin sister until she was 2.

Alma_Wheeler_Smith_campaign_25.jpg

Smith gives a stump speech to a crowd of Democrats last month.

Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com

"I come to you with a wealth of experience that grew from a family tragedy and that was the death of my identical twin sister when she caught her dress on fire," she told a crowd last month. "And the ambulance that came to take Lucille to the hospital left her to die in my mother's arms because the family was black. At that time, my parents taught their daughters that the color of your skin, the depth of your wallet, and the place where you live must never determine or limit your opportunities for a great quality of life."

Smith moved with her family to Michigan when she was 2. Since 1978, she has lived in Salem Township where her three now-adult children grew up.

Smith graduated from the University of Michigan with a degree in journalism and did advanced degree work in political science and business administration. She worked as a senior television producer at U-M prior to running for office.

In Lansing, Smith led the Democrats on the Senate Appropriations Committee and, as a member of the House Appropriations Committee, continues to influence the state's budget.

Known for her own brand of straight talk, Smith promised in her short-lived campaign to speak truthfully with the citizens of Michigan.

"We need a governor who will not pander to you and tell you what they think you want to hear, but will tell you what you need to hear," she said. "I will be always honest. My record is high for integrity. It's going to be a tough job for governor and I am prepared."

Smith campaigned on the promise that her policies and budgets would support full access to health care for each resident, equal education access and opportunity from preschool to grad school, a safe and clean environment, vital urban centers and recovery for Detroit, a healthy business sector, and protection for civil rights and liberties.

She criticized a broken Lansing.

"You lost your financial aid because we went for an all-cuts budget," she told a crowd of mostly college students last month. "That's bad leadership. I am changing the leadership in Lansing. As governor of the state of Michigan, we will have a free tuition program for our community colleges, our vocational tech centers, and public universities in the state of Michigan. And we will pay for that program by raising revenue in the state."

Smith called herself "the only candidate who is being honest with the electorate" by talking about raising tax revenue.

"If we hope to turn Michigan around, if we hope to create jobs, if we want to have the public sector be a leader in that job creation — and put our people to work on the grid, on our infrastructure, with our students in front of the classroom — then you need a governor who is going to talk to them honestly about raising revenue," she said.

Smith has authored laws that established genetic privacy rights, regulated personal protection orders between juveniles and their parents or guardians, provided the first state funding for a successful drug court program, shared in the establishment of the first early childhood education programs, and brought state law into conformity with federal disability terminology.

Alma_Wheeler_Smith_campaign_5.jpg

Smith mingles with supporters while campaigning last month.

Ryan J. Stanton | AnnArbor.com

Smith said her long experience in the Legislature has given her the ability to judge when government is off track and how to correct it.

"As governor of the state of Michigan, I am the only candidate with a solid plan that will turn this state around: jobs, education, making sure that we don't just talk about the quality of the health care plan that was passed — the first step toward universal health care — but we talk about how we implement that here at the state," she said. "You need a governor who will be standing up for your rights and for your children's rights, who is going to be strong, tough, knowledgeable and undefeatable. I am that candidate."

Stuart Dowty, a retired attorney and chairman of the Washtenaw County Democratic Party, said the local party is sad to see Smith drop out of the race.

"But we respect it and doing it now shows her principles," he said. "I think what Alma said in her statement about looking at the nature of the race, and her candidacy along with Bernero probably splitting the progressive vote is well taken. It speaks well to Alma to make that kind of decision."

Dowty said the county party doesn't support any one candidate in a contested primary, so it hasn't taken a position yet in the race.

"But certainly Alma, because of her roots and ties here in Washtenaw County, was loved and had a lot of support," he said. "She was willing to raise issues about fundamental questions about our tax structure and the economic conditions of the state that other candidates haven't had the courage to raise directly the way she has. And she's certainly — and this has been true her whole career — one of the best politicians or legislators in terms of being willing to speak truth to power. She's willing to speak up and go to the real issues rather than play after what seems to be popular at the moment."

Dowty predicts Michigan hasn't seen the last of Smith politically. In fact, some predict she may end up being Bernero's choice for lieutenant governor.

"Alma is a friend, a colleague, and a fellow crusader in the fight to take Michigan back from the special interests and to stand up for the little guy," Bernero said. "She was a tough competitor in Michigan’s Democratic gubernatorial primary. She too has been a strong advocate for working families who are struggling against the banks and insurance companies. Alma has always stood up for what’s right and never backed down from a fight, no matter how long the odds."

Ryan J. Stanton covers government for AnnArbor.com. Reach him at ryanstanton@annarbor.com or 734-623-2529.

Comments

Speechless

Wed, May 12, 2010 : 6:59 a.m.

A centerpiece of Alma's tax reform plan, as I understand it, involves changing the state constitution to allow a progressive income tax (there's that prog word again!) in place of the current fixed percentage -- something that many other states can already do. As heard while listening to WUOM yesterday afternoon, she would propose reworking the tax structure so that those making under $50K (or thereabouts) annually would actually pay less than they do now, while earners above that threshold would pay more than they do currently. In other words, a progressive structure would bring welcome tax relief for those who need it, while asking a higher contribution from those who can much more easily afford it. Total proceeds to state government would increase, additionally allowing for a reduction of the state business tax. Up above, Alma is quoted as saying, "We need to tax the wealth of the state of Michigan, not the poor people of the state of Michigan...."

leaguebus

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 2:38 p.m.

Alma Smith has worked very hard to make things better for the people of Michigan and she deserves many thanks for this. By the way, the Progressives did not bring us Unions. The sweat shops at the turn of the 19th century brought us Unions. Men, women, and children working 16 hour days for little or nothing, brought us Unions. Actually a few of the Unions were started by Communists, especially on the east coast. By the way, the Conservative Reagan and both Bush administrations did cut taxes, but they also quadrupled the gross national debt. The tax and spend Clinton administration actually lowered the debt from 63% of the GDP to 58% of the GDP. Then W raised it from 58% to 80% of the GDP. So quit flaming the tax and spend Progressives. Same thing here in Michigan, Engler cuts taxes, keeps spending and the economy is good, no problems. Once the economy goes into the dumpster, revenues go lower, and the state goes further into the dumpster. Now we are laying off police, fire, and teachers by the droves. Its easy to blame the progressives for all these problems, but sorry, its the Conservative GOP that has done the real damage. The URL for the deficit data is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Federal_Debt_as_Percent_of_GDP_by_President.jpg

Conan Smith

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 12:48 p.m.

Thanks, Ryan, for a nice story and some wonderful photographs that we'll treasure. My mother's smile says it all. She really loves working for Michigan, and I know she'll be missed by people on both sides of the aisle. She is one of the hardest working, most honest people I've ever known. Growing up I would see her poring over reports and studies and legislative proposal into the small hours of the morning. I don't believe she ever took a vote on something she hadn't read cover to cover and exhaustively analyzed. Even when you argued with her (which I have one more than one occasion and intend to do for many more years!) you always had to begrudgingly admit that she knew her stuff as well as anyone. As a liberal, or a progressive or whatever, I wish she were in this race still. And I can certainly understand why people on the right celebrate that her legislative career is ending -- she has certainly advocated a different set of policies. But politics aside, she's been a model representative for a more civil society that doesn't dismiss differences but tries to understand and accommodate them. That kind of thinking sets her apart and should be lauded by anyone who loves and values democracy.

Mick52

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 12:03 p.m.

I see nothing different from Ms. Wheeler Smith than any other democratic candidate for a major office. She promises an awful lot, free tuition for all public colleges? health care? vital urban centers and a recovered Detroit? All are admirable goals, but wow, extremely costly. No surprise she will raise taxes (democrat) but to promise so much without telling us: just exactly how are you going to do this...and how much tax increase are you thinking?" is somewhat short sighted. To promise so much, really unattainable, without laying out what it will take and how is old fashioned politicking. All this with a federal govt immersed in out of control spending. I do admire her for noting a tax increase is needed-no republican will do so-but for what? I prefer it to maintain state service, not inflate it. I agree with Inside the Hall, until Michigan does something to break the union hold on employment, Michigan is going to have a hard time attracting business. Is any democrat willing to take that step? Here is another thing that bugs me: "Unfortunately, until we do campaign finance reform, it is going to be about who gets the bucks." I am getting kind of tired of hearing how everything needs "reform." The people who get the bucks are the preferred candidates.

Ram

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 11 a.m.

Progressives brought us unions, didn't they? Brotherhood over individualism! Don't advance too much - your neighbor might feel left out!

Carl Johnson

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 10 a.m.

Hmmmmm, well if she was running for governor, wouldn't that make her a "gubernatorial" candidate? The headline sounds kind of awkward to me... Though perhaps to the unenlightened "gubernatorial" may bring The Andy Griffith Show to mind.

Wolverine3660

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 9:28 a.m.

The Democratic Party in Michigan finally got smart, and didnt support Ms Smith, whose ideas and policy prescriptions, would have put Michigan further into the whole.

Alan Benard

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:27 a.m.

Alma Wheeler Smith represents Democrats in Michigan tired of the state party's spinelessness, inaction and corruption. We are held hostage to business interests intent on dismantling all aspects of government which serve and protect people, and the party does less than nothing at all to stop this. Witness the shabby treatment of Connie Saltonstall, stonewalled by the party in her run for Bart Stupak's seat. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/10/AR2010051003417.htmlBut the last presidential election cycle made it clear that we Democrats don't deserve primaries. We are expected to shut up and let the old boys decide. So long as people with vision like Saltonstall and Wheeler Smith are dumped by the Michigan Democratic Party, and ineffectual loser liberals like Grandholm throw the game, the state will continue to function for interests other than those of the people of Michigan.

Ed Lahoa

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:22 a.m.

Whether you agree or disagree with her political philosophy, Rep. Smith was the only candidate honest enough to put forward a real plan to eliminate the state's structural budget gap. The GOP candidates all want to (1) cut taxes further and (2) restore the Promise Grant Program, without saying (3) where they'd make the large budget reductions (on top of those that have already been made) to pay for those things.

Plubius

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:19 a.m.

Anyone who speaks to party first and the State second will not get my vote.

dading dont delete me bro

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:16 a.m.

a broken lansing...that's good. i'm still (still) waiting to be blown away by ms.granholm.

L. C. Burgundy

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:12 a.m.

Well bob, Do not taunt Happy Fun Ball is nothing if not accurate: She criticized a broken Lansing. "You lost your financial aid because we went for an all-cuts budget," she told a crowd of mostly college students last month. "That's bad leadership. I am changing the leadership in Lansing. As governor of the state of Michigan, we will have a free tuition program for our community colleges, our vocational tech centers, and public universities in the state of Michigan. And we will pay for that program by raising revenue in the state." If that's not the old "Vote for me and I'll give you someone else's money" schtick, nothing is. Alma Wheeler Smith had zero chance of winning in the fall anyway, because her act plays well in Ann Arbor and East Lansing (and Detroit, maybe), but virtually nowhere else. It would have been a challenge for to break even 40% statewide in a general election.

Freemind42

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 8:08 a.m.

I have to agree with Think! on this one. Blaming one part or the other overly simplistic and completely partisan. Both groups have ignored the changing dynamics of the global economy for 40 years. We have depended on manufacturing as our only source of economic production and we're getting burned by it. Everyone is to blame, not just Republicans or Democrats.

bs

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 7:50 a.m.

Did any of your mothers ever teach you the word "respect"?

Do not taunt Happy Fun Ball

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 7:14 a.m.

Looks like the "Something for Nothing Crowd" has lost one of it's leaders.

Think!

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 7:14 a.m.

I respectfully disagree with Inside the hall. Ms Smith has reached access the isle to build coalitions, listens to people's points of view. Is inclusive of everyone's needs. I don't see anything wrong with progressive or liberal. If you want to know the truth, in 1978 when Chrysler received its first bail out, Michigan was warned to change its direction. It never did. we are paying the piper now.

dading dont delete me bro

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 5:35 a.m.

i won't loose any sleep over her not running

InsideTheHall

Tue, May 11, 2010 : 4:58 a.m.

Progressive is a code word for liberal. A2.com should trace the roots of the "progressive" era back to the Wilson days. If nothing else it is a true journalistic exercise. Smith is part of the old guard that destroyed the state of Michigan failing to react to the changing global economy dynamics. Smith clung to the union interests contributing to a state business environment rated near the bottom. Smith failed the very people she pledged to help.