Health notes: Community can help increase cardiac arrest survival rates, U-M researcher says
4 Comments. Comment Now
Survival rates for cardiac arrests outside of the hospital have changed very little in the past 30 years despite increased health spending, recent University of Michigan research linking data from around the nation showed.
According to the study, the city where a person lives could play a big role in whether that person survives a cardiac arrest.
For instance, Detroit has the worst rate of survival among cities examined around the nation with .2 percent of those who have cardiac arrest outside the hospital surviving the episode. In comparison, 16.3 percent of those who go into cardiac arrest outside of the hospital in the Seattle area survive. The average national survival rate is 7.6 percent.
A big difference between Seattle and Detroit is largely the rate that bystanders step in and perform CPR, said Comilla Sasson, an emergency medicine physician at U-M and lead author of the study. Seattle’s rate of bystander CPR is more than 50 percent while the national average is closer to 1 in 3 people receiving bystander CPR.
Other factors determining cardiac arrest survival included whether or not a person had a shockable heart rhythm. The lack of progress could be linked to an aging population, lower number of people with the shockable heart rhythm or longer EMS drives because of growing cities or traffic congestion, the study found.
The biggest determining factor for survival appeared to be whether or not a heartbeat was restored at the scene with 15.5 percent survival in low-performing EMS systems and 33.6 percent in high-performing EMS symptoms surviving.
These findings support the idea that EMS crews should stay and attempt to restore a pulse on the scene where they have extra support rather than following the “scoop and go” model of restoring a pulse in the back of a speeding ambulance, Sasson said.
“What we’re trying to say is there are things we can do in our communities — in Detroit, in Ann Arbor — to improve our survival rates without expensive technology,” Sasson said.
See a video on how to perform CPR from the American Heart Association.
Some of those measures could include increased numbers of those who understand CPR recommendations, 911 dispatchers trained in explaining CPR over the telephone and increased awareness of where automated external defibrillators, or AEDs, are located, she said.
U-M boasts nearly 400 'Best Doctors'
Nearly 400 University of Michigan Health System physicians were recognized on a list of “Best Doctors in America,” the health system announced on Monday.
The list is compiled every two years by Best Doctors Inc. and is based on a survey of 45,000 physicians in 43 specialties and more than 400 subspecialties in medicine.
There are more than 1,600 faculty physicians treat patients in the U-M health system and several hundred others who are affiliated with the health system.
Study supports program for increasing medication adherence
Pharmacy-based interventions can help patients with serious mental illnesses stick to their regular medication regimens, U-M researchers found recently.
The study examined a particular pharmacy-based intervention program called MedsHelp in which pharmacy staff members were the contacts for patient questions regarding pharmacy services or doctor prescriptions. After a year, those patients who were enrolled in MedsHelp filled their medications 86 percent of the time, compared to 62 percent of patients receiving usual care, U-M said in a release.
The study of 118 patients in four VA facilities with either schizophrenia or bipolar disorder was published online in the Schizophrenia Bulletin.
“Because 40 percent of patients with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder have difficulty taking their medications regularly, we need to develop low cost, practical and non-coercive ways to help them become more adherent,” said lead researcher Marcia Valenstein, senior research scientist in the Veterans Administration Health Services Research and Development Service and U-M Medical School psychiatry professor.
Tina Reed covers health and the environment for AnnArbor.com. You can reach her at tinareed@annarbor.com, call her at 734-623-2535 or find her on Twitter @TreedinAA.
It's important to point out that no matter how many of the best doctors in the world you have standing by AT THE HOSPITAL... your life is saved by the first responders that arrive to your home. If those responders can't deliver you to the hospital alive, then a team of 400 doctors won't do you any good.
It's amazing how many people don't know how to do CPR. The "I'll learn that one day" attitude is nice until your husband/wife, father/mother, or son/daughter drops in front of you. The time to learn how to CPR is not when you're on the phone with a dispatcher for the first time and your loved one is dying in front of you.
People... learn this stuff!
Daycare providers are required by law to know basic first aid and CPR. Those providers have your children for 8 hours a day. How many parents out there know it? Makes you think...
(Flag this Post)
Posted Nov 23 2009
BornNRaised: You bring up a great point about how many people do not know CPR. When I spoke with Comilla Sasson, she really did emphasize the importance of putting efforts toward getting more bystanders comfortable with being able to help in the case of a cardiac arrest. While actually getting the training is optimal, she said, even getting a larger part of the population to take the time to watch a one-minute online tutorial to understand the American Heart Association's guidelines for "hands-only CPR," can be helpful. There is also an iPhone application that offers step-by-step instructions on how to perform CPR. Those who have an iPhone might want to download that just in case, she suggested.
AnnArbor.com Staff
(Flag this Post)
Posted Nov 23 2009
"Detroit has the worst rate of survival among cities examined around the nation with .2 percent of those who have cardiac arrest outside the hospital surviving the episode. In comparison, 16.3 percent of those who go into cardiac arrest outside of the hospital in the Seattle" Is that 0.2% in Detroit? Not 2.0%????
(Flag this Post)
Posted Nov 23 2009
Yes, it's true "The biggest determining factor for survival appeared to be whether or not a heartbeat was restored at the scene". To do that an Automated External Defibrillator (AED) is needed.
And, as Dr. Sasson noted, improvements to survival include 911 dispatchers trained in explaining CPR over the telephone and increased awareness of where automated external defibrillators, or AEDs, are located.
The problem is that 911 dispatchers don’t know where the nearest AED is, nor do potential citizen first responders. Therefore, people are still dying in places with AEDs.
Our AED Link system is designed to close the missing link in the chain of survival (between “Call 911” and “Early Defibrillation”) because AEDs do not save lives. People quickly using an AED save lives. But a person cannot quickly use an AED if they don’t know where one is in the time of need.
Our White Paper: “People are dying in buildings with AEDs” is available on request by emailing erfisch@atrusinc.com.
(Flag this Post)
Posted Nov 24 2009