You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 11:52 a.m.

Lunch hour: A time for Pioneer students to unwind or another hectic part of the day?

By Jeff Kass

A few years ago, my family took a trip to California during spring break to visit relatives. While staying with my brother-in-law’s family in Davis, I realized just how long a high-school student’s school day really is.

In the morning, my wife and I would wake up at 7 a.m. to chat with our nieces - one a junior, the other a senior - while they shoveled down a quick breakfast. When the girls left at 7:10, we’d go back to bed for an hour or so, then wake back up and make breakfast for our own kids at maybe 8:30. 

Since we were on vacation, we’d enjoy a rare unhurried meal, maybe even read the morning paper. Then we’d take the kids out for a long walk, glorying in the milder weather after enduring a harsh Michigan winter. We might hang out at a park for a while before heading back for lunch at around noon and after that - still exhausted from months of sleep deprivation - I cherished the chance to crash on the couch and take a not insubstantial afternoon nap. 

I’d wake up at three o’clock or so, play with the kids some more, maybe read to them for a while, and my nieces still would not have returned. Shortly after four, they’d finally make it home and then wind down for maybe half an hour before heading upstairs to begin cracking their homework. They’d break for an hour for dinner at around six, then resume working until they went to sleep at about eleven.

Brutal.

I guess when I’m at school and churning through the hours, strategizing from moment to moment about how to best transition from one activity to the next, I don’t really think about how long the day might feel from a student’s perspective. It took getting away and experiencing how much time actually elapses while my nieces are at school for me to really understand the length of their day. When I returned to teaching the following week, I did so with a renewed sense of empathy, a little more sympathy for that kid whose eyelids start to droop when I grow enchanted by my own marvelous insights and run my mouth in excessive lecture mode.

I bring up this mini-epiphany because something similar happened last Friday when I met a couple of students for lunch. We’re currently working on writing group poems in class and, having inserted myself into a group, I thought my groupmates and I could bond a little if we shared a meal off-campus and that we’d then trust each other in a more meaningful way, allowing for greater risk-taking in our writing. 

We agreed on a burrito place not far from Pioneer and we ended up being the first people at the counter to order food in what was in that moment an empty restaurant. Within seconds, 30 to 40 other kids from Pioneer had crowded in line behind us. After paying for our meals, we sat in a booth and I dug into my chicken quesadilla.

I’m not a slow eater, and I didn’t feel like my quesadilla-chomping pace was particularly lethargic as we hashed out a few ideas amid a boisterous atmosphere as the other Pioneer kids got their food and also began to eat. The burritos my students ordered disappeared almost instantly and, after I spent a couple of minutes quizzing them about their college plans for next year, I looked down at the remaining third of my quesadilla and realized we were now once again sitting in a quiet and empty restaurant. All the other Pioneer students had already plowed through their food and left.

The Pioneer High School lunch period is from 10:46 a.m. until 11:27. Forty-one minutes. Subtract a dozen of those minutes to account for getting from class to car and from car to class and you’re talking roughly 29 minutes for a kid to drive to a local eatery; order, receive and inhale his food; and drive back if he doesn’t want to be late for his next class and suffer the consequences of a tardy sweep. Car accidents are not infrequent.

From my standard perch at my desk, or at the photocopier in the English office, I knew the lunch period at Pioneer passed quickly, but it took my experiencing what the students go through for me to really understand the insanity of the situation. From a digestive standpoint, it can’t be healthy to cram food down one’s throat so hurriedly and it’s certainly not relaxing, certainly not conducive to inculcating the kind of life-long wholesome eating habits advocated by people like Alice Waters.

The obvious solution is to simply stop allowing students to leave campus for lunch. That’s the direction Pioneer appears to be headed. But the matter deserves more thought. The school day is long and it makes total sense to me why kids would relish the chance to escape campus in the middle of it, even if it’s only for a whirlwind half-hour. Isn’t it possible that a longer (safer and healthier) lunch period would allow greater opportunity for kids to rejuvenate themselves, thereby leading to enhanced learning in their afternoon classes?

I don’t know the answer to that question, but I know it’s worth asking. I know I still feel cheated because I suspect that chicken quesadilla probably tasted pretty good, but tearing through the last third of it was such a blur, I honestly don’t remember.

** NOTE ** Speaking of rejuvenating … The Ann Arbor Book Festival is offering a special fall Writer’s Conference on Saturday, Nov. 14 at Pioneer High School. A spectacular slate of instructors includes Eileen Pollack and Michael Byers from the University of Michigan's #2 nationally ranked MFA program in Creative Writing, as well as local poets and incomparable workshop leaders Keith Taylor, Scott Beal and Susan Hutton; and I’ll be offering a seminar on how to present/perform your work in public. The day’s a great value at $95, including three workshop sessions, lunch, a panel discussion on publishing options and a participant reading. $50 for students. To register and/or glean additional info, go to aabookfestival.org.

Jeff Kass teaches Creative Writing at Pioneer High School in Ann Arbor and at Eastern Michigan University in Ypsilanti, and directs the Literary Arts Programs at the Neutral Zone, including the VOLUME Youth Poetry Project which meets every Thursday night at 7pm. He will post new blog entries every Tuesday and Thursday morning throughout the school year.

Comments

hattrix

Thu, Nov 5, 2009 : 1:30 p.m.

We spent some time living in Australia, and when you ask my daughter what the biggest difference was between school here (AAPS middle school) and school there, her answer is, "Over there, we had an hour for lunch and 10 minutes between classes!" Never mind the fact that she attended an all-girls school, wore a uniform, took two foreign languages and was in a class of 17 students! The lunch break is valuable downtime as well as a great chance for kids to catch up with their friends each day, and it's too bad we can't seem to do much about this.

RhondaM

Thu, Nov 5, 2009 : 12:54 p.m.

I went to Pioneer over 10 yrs ago. That's when they were just starting to let us go out for lunch. I never ate breakfast because Lunch was at 10:15am (or so), then I was still only hungry for a yogurt. Ann Arbor Schools are not as great as they hype them up to be. BTW I used to go home to eat lunch so that I wouldn't eat fast food, and to get off campus for 15 min.

peihaha

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 8:36 p.m.

Jeff, can you send your article to our education policy makers? Not only the lunch period is a mess up (who eats lunch at 10:20am within 20 minutes) the morning class start time is anti-humane. According to research, adolescence needs more sleep then young children and adults. Their bodies are developing so fast and they need enough of sleep and nutrition to sustain their daily life. Classes start at 7:45am requires some kids to be at the bus stop before dawn. Then they have to rush through the early lunch period, squeeze into the hallway, getting high GPA, perfect SAT scores, being a perfect athlete and perfect musician, etc., on top of the social intensity, bullies, identity issue, etc., etc. Whenever I heard a high school or college freshman committing suicide my heart just pinched. College admission officers claim that they are looking for young adults that are capable, productive and well rounded. I am afraid on the other side of the college acceptance letter there are the young adults who suffer from serious mental and physical health issues.

Carol Burgener

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 7:01 p.m.

The lunch break is too short to safely leave campus for a reasonable lunch. For safety's sake, the administration should be working to make on-campus lunch a desirable alternative. Unfortunately, they are doing just the opposite.

m macke

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 5:11 p.m.

I have had kids eating lunch in my room at Pioneer for 10 years. Some of the conversations that I overhear kids having during are every bit as educational (or sadly, sometimes more so) than the educational experiences they have in class. Kids NEED time to have intelligent conversations with their peers, and the shortened lunch has really damaged these opportunities. Many of the clubs meet at lunch; kids get help at lunch; lunch is a valuable period. Lunch isn't just about eating, it is an extra period where kids have complete control of the lesson.

treetowncartel

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 4:32 p.m.

Ah, lunches off campus with a little help from my friends, those were the days.

Jake C

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 4:16 p.m.

"Shortly after four, theyd finally make it home and then wind down for maybe half an hour before heading upstairs to begin cracking their homework. Theyd break for an hour for dinner at around six, then resume working until they went to sleep at about eleven." Were you actually supervising any of this homework to make sure that these kids were actually *doing* homework for a full 4-5 hours straight and then immediately going to bed? I worked 3-4 hours after school, completed in JV tennis in the spring, worked all summer, and I still managed to graduate as my class valedictorian. And yet high school was still one of the best times in my life so far. And my school had a 50-minute lunch (including the 5-minute "between class" segments, which seems about in line with Pioneer). If we wanted to leave campus, we knew we were dealing with a 10-15 minute drive each way and a moderate wait at a drive-thru. That's just part of the "off-campus" experience. If we really cared about a guarantee that we would get to our next class on time, we wouldn't leave campus during lunch. It's not the school's responsibility to ensure there's a McDonalds 2 blocks from campus, it's their responsibility to ensure a quality education.

Rod Johnson

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 3:39 p.m.

At Skyline, my daughter has first lunch, which is not only absurdly short but starts at 10:20! She's never hungry by then, and often doesn't eat, and then there's no chance to eat until (during field hockey season) 5:30, seven hours later! This seems crazy and counterproductive to me, but apparently, as Dante said, this has been willed where what is willed must be.

Jennifer Shikes Haines

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 1:37 p.m.

Your nieces' days actually sound light, compared to many of our A2 kids - where are all the extra-curriculars they need/want both for something non-academic and to round out that all-important college application? My DS often uses lunch hours to get extra help from teachers, etc., and his days at school (being part of the CHS theater group) tend to run from 7:50 - 6:30 and then HW starts at 7:00. The thing I find most fascinating in all of this is that research proves again and again (ie. one of the most recent studies is the ONLY factor that all National Merit Scholars seem to have in common) is that children of families who eat dinner together succeed at higher rates. Wouldn't there be at least a somewhat similar correlation for students who can get a decent break with peers during the day and have some time to BE kids? Great article, Jeff.

CLX

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 12:40 p.m.

My elementary school kids get 20 minutes or so to eat. After that, they are told to leave the cafeteria so that another group can come in. Slow eaters are not allowed to stay. While they get an additional 20 + minutes outside, it has to be unhealthy, not to mention the fact that my daughter never finishes her meal.

Wolverine3660

Tue, Nov 3, 2009 : 7:23 a.m.

I went to a school where we got an hour and fifteen minutes to eat lunch, and relax a bit. Th e kids in the Ann Arbor Public Schools ought to get at least an hour, especially the younger kids.