You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 5:58 a.m.

New WISD superintendent Scott Menzel talks finances, consolidation and goals

By Kyle Feldscher

New Washtenaw Intermediate School District superintendent Scott Menzel is still transitioning into his new role, but he believes his familiarity with the area is helping his adjustment.

Menzel spent the period from 2002 to 2007 as the superintendent of Whitmore Lake Public Schools before leaving to take over as superintendent of the Livingston Educational Service Agency, the Livingston County equivalent of the WISD. He took over from interim superintendent Richard Leyshock, who held the job from January until the end of June after the retirement of former superintendent William Miller.

Menzel said he’s thrilled to be back in the county and in a position to improve the school experience for students from Manchester to Willow Run.

“I’m excited about the opportunities we have in Washtenaw County to ensure that every child has the chance to get a successful and positive education,” he said. “It’s an outstanding community.”

scott-menzel.jpg

WISD superintendent Scott Menzel

Courtesy of the WISD

The WISD will have an $89.83 million budget for the 2011-12 school year, with all but about $6 million spent on special education services and reimbursing county school districts for special education. Approximately $66 million of that spending will go to local school districts as reimbursements, with the rest being spent on WISD programs.

The WISD employs about 400 people, according to spokesperson Gerri Allen. The WISD school board approved four layoffs for the 2011-12 school year, according to district documents. However, Allen said there may not be any displaced staff due to attrition and other program needs.

The WISD enrolls 233 students, mainly for special education programs.

Menzel sat down with AnnArbor.com to answer a few questions about how he's approaching his new position.

The WISD spent down about $12 million in fund balance in the 2011-12 budget and there have been some questions about what’s going to happen next year. How are you working with the WISD’s finances to make sure the services are still the same things you provide in good times as well?

Menzel: Well, I think the financial challenges for intermediate school districts as well as local school districts are going to be real and ongoing. We have taken a very specific and intentional stance as to when we spend our fund balance with the constituent districts. None of these decisions are made in isolation.

At the end of the day, we make our resource allocation by what will make improvements in student achievement and that will always be the core question for the WISD, so as we look at what those opportunities are sometimes we need to think outside the box. We need to think about other opportunities there are to create revenue so we can create and maintain those services for students. I think that’s kind of where we’re at.

Where are you looking right now within the organization to find more efficient spending or to make things more streamlined to find those savings?

In some respects, it’s still early in the conversation. I’m still gathering information about the structure of the organization. We have the opportunity to reflect how we’re structured because we have some retirements coming in key positions; we have veteran leaders who will be leaving us by the end of August. We’ve begun the process of having a discussion about if we can achieve some efficiencies in how we’re structured as a result of that change in leadership.

There are a lot of people in the county who don’t know what the WISD does. How will you communicate your role in the community?

Generally speaking, if we speak about WISD students or parents of students who have disabilities, so they may be familiar with some of the services and support we provide. That would be logical. It’s typical for ISDs in may cases to be synonymous with special education services, but going beyond that we’ve been engaged in expanding opportunities with our partnerships with constituent districts through our secondary options programs.

The Early College Alliance, the WAY (Widening Advancement for Youth) program, the Washtenaw International High School will be starting this fall, so we have an opportunity in those areas to raise awareness about what the WISD does in partnership with constituent districts because we have students enrolled in programs.

Another is we need to take advantage of social media and getting information out there. We need to be intentional — we’re not going to jump into the deep end of the pool without really thinking through the strategies about how we can maximize that communication. I think that’s another way to raise awareness of what the WISD does and the services that it provides not only to constituent districts but also directly to students and the larger community.

The programs like the ECA, WAY programs have already started, and the IB program is set to start in the fall. What are you seeing in those programs and how have you familiarized yourself with them and how will you work to make sure those programs stick around and are a success?

While I was in Whitmore Lake, we were one of the four districts that were partners in the launch of the Early College Alliance so I’m familiar with the ECA from its inception. We also launched a WAY program in Livingston at the same time they launched it here, so I’ve got experience with launching that program from the beginning and can provide the support to ensure it's successful. It’s an innovative way of approaching learning for students and I think we need to be very intentional as to how we assess the success of the program.

At the end of the day, this is really about achievement. We need to ensure that whatever we’re doing raises the level of achievement for the students we serve.

With respect to the International High School, we’ll provide the support that we need to ensure its successful. I think it will provide an important service to students in the community — it’s an outstanding program and students who graduate from the International High School will be prepared to succeed in college and in life.

A lot of districts in the county, instead of looking at nearby districts, are looking to consolidate on a countywide level. How do you see the WISD and yourself facilitating that?

Again, the relationship between the constituent districts and the WISD is critical to moving forward in this conversation, but the economic reality is such we need to look at sharing resources and services, so whether that’s human resources or business office opportunities, we look to see does it make sense on a countywide level? With respect to the regional transportation, not everyone signed on but it made sense for those three. We look to identify those opportunities across the county where we can identify true cost savings that will free up resources to allow what’s most important: the teaching and learning aspect of our work.

There’s an openness in the county to rethinking how we do things and there’s a commitment from the superintendents group to do that, and they’ve formalized that commitment and the boards are open to it. Those are ongoing conversations.

We also don’t want to consolidate to simply say that we did it. If it doesn’t save money and/or improve student achievement, it probably doesn’t make sense to do it. We’re going to be very intentional about collecting data and making sure consolidation makes sense and will work. One of the challenges we have in the business service area is that we don’t all have the same software to operate those systems. We’re in the process of talking about how do we get to a common platform and once we get to a common platform, we can consolidate and share more easily.

Kyle Feldscher covers K-12 education for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at kylefeldscher@annarbor.com or you can follow him on Twitter.

Comments

John Smith

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 6:32 p.m.

Why do we need a superintendent for an ISD? Why do we need an ISD? Article says WISD spends $90million, employs 400 people to educate 233 students. OK, $66million are passed back to school districts; why have the "middle man"? Still have $24million and 400 employees for 233 students, about $100K per student. What is the state foundation grant, about $7K per student? (Ann Arbor gets $2K more for some reason.)

DonBee

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 7:02 p.m.

Those 233 students are the most severely challenged when it comes to education. In most cases the classrooms contain fewer than 15 students (the state limit for this classification) and have a teacher and potentially one or more aids. The WISD now employs the technology staff for several of the school districts and also the bus drivers for 3 districts that consolidated busing. So the ISD does more than educate the 233 students. By having a single location to teach the most severely challenged at one location, medical support staff and other specialist do not have to be replicated at several locations.

janofmi

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 6:12 p.m.

Given some time to get his feet on the ground I feel that most will find that the WISD Board did a great service to the children in Washtenaw County by hiring Mr. Menzel.

Dog Guy

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 4:12 p.m.

Did Menzel happen to mention how he plans to spend the "special education" millage?

Kyle Feldscher

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 7:38 p.m.

Dog Guy, the break down of where the money from the special education millage will go is in this story: <a href="http://www.annarbor.com/news/early-returns-show-wisd-special-education-millage-renewal-passing-handily/">http://www.annarbor.com/news/early-returns-show-wisd-special-education-millage-renewal-passing-handily/</a>

DonBee

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 1:54 p.m.

I am disappointed with the tone of this article. I would expect a much more aggresive stance on consolidation of non-classroom services. Having been at WISD for a couple of months, I would expect the the new Superintendent would be able to provide at least a decision timeline. This is really a softball article for the issues that face statewide education.

Kyle Feldscher

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 7:39 p.m.

Menzel did begin working at the WISD on July 1. He has been meeting with former superintendent Richard Leyshock quite a bit since he was hired in April, but he formally took over at the beginning of the month.

janofmi

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 6:09 p.m.

Wasn't his start date, July 1?

Cash

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 10:53 a.m.

If I recall correctly, during the campaign for a new millage, the district said it was &quot;negotiating&quot; a contract and salary for this gentleman. Thus, the new salary could not be announced before the election. That was several months ago. What is his salary?

alarictoo

Thu, Jul 28, 2011 : 12:45 p.m.

And @Cash is here saying: &quot;Show me the money!&quot; ;^)