You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Mon, Apr 26, 2010 : 7:20 a.m.

Ann Arbor's 'sign language' is always a good read

By Lon Horwedel

042510_reflection1.jpg

SIGNS, SIGNS, EVERYWHERE A SIGN: The Diag at the University of Michigan was a sea of signs during the April 15 Tea Party rally.

Lon Horwedel | AnnArbor.com

When I moved to Ann Arbor 15 years ago, it was quite a cultural shock for me, a small-town boy from the fruit farms of northern Ohio.

Where I’m from, the only thing remotely resembling diversity went something like this: “Do you grow apples, or do you grow peaches?” Differences of opinion, if there were any, were discussed at the local coffee shop.

For the most part, life was harmonious and we all got along. Certainly no one asked, or cared, whom you voted for in the last election, or where you stood on the major issues. We focused our talk, instead, on fertilizers and insecticides.

That all changed when I rolled into Ann Arbor, the “capital of diversity” a decade and a half ago. It wasn’t like I was that naïve. I mean I didn’t ramble into town in an old Ford pickup wearing overalls and smoking a corncob pipe. Heck, I’d even been to college! But nothing in this world could prepare me for the Ann Arbor experience - which, I might point out, is different for everybody.

For example, I don’t drink coffee, so imagine how much of the A2 experience I’m missing out on there? Also, I really hate soccer. And, believe it or not, I don’t have one single bumper sticker on my car, and I’ve never actively participated in a protest.

How could this be, you ask? How in the world could a non-coffee drinking, soccer-hating, bumper-stickerless, 44-year-old man live in this town?

Well, I am a curious sort, and I do like to read - not that you’ll find me hanging out at one of the roughly 1,500 bookstores in Ann Arbor. No, I’m more a connoisseur of the short read, and thanks to all those bumper stickers and protest signs that propagate so freely in this town, it seems I’m never at a loss for good reading material.

If I can’t satiate my quest for word play at my local intersection, all I have to do is head for the Federal Building, Kerrytown, or the granddaddy of them all - The University of Michigan Diag - where I’m sure to be bombarded by a library’s worth of unique phrases and catchy political slogans via the protest sign.

That’s the cool thing about Ann Arbor. On any given day, at any given place and any given time, you’re likely to encounter some sort of protest. And the one thing a protest has over bumper stickers is originality. That’s not to say that bumper stickers aren’t original or quirky, they’re just not all that unique since they’re mass-produced. Protest signs, on the other hand, are generally made one at a time - sometimes right on the spot!

042510_reflection2.jpg

NICE MESSAGE: It's hard to argue with this sign.

Lon Horwedel | AnnArbor.com

And with every passing year, the signs seem to get more and more creative - and bigger! Often times a simple little sign may blossom into a gigantic banner, a peace dove, or even a float! But the April 15th TEA (Taxed Enough Already) Party protest on The Diag, definitely took the cake when it came to both the number of signs, and the diversity of the signage.

Of course, as with every protest, all the usual suspects were there - and by that I mean the true signs of the times. Right away you know who the president is, who likes him, and who doesn’t. This protest was no different in that regard, but it was different in that the sheer number of the signs, and their varying degrees of cleverness, seemed to drown out the actual message of the protest.

For every “Give Me Liberty, Not Debt” sign floating about, there was a “I love Puppies!” (And who doesn’t, really?) For every perfectly cut, and printed, “We will REMEMBER, in NOVEMBER” there was a sloppy, handwritten “Bring Back Led Zeppelin.”

It was hard to estimate the crowd size; because most were holding at least two, sometimes three signs. And gazing out over The Diag, it was hard to actually see the people hidden behind the clutter of Magic Markered poster board.

It got to the point where people were making them up on the spot. One U-M student brought an entire package of blank poster board and a black Sharpie with him, stood behind the main speakers on the library steps, and tried his best to became a performance art piece as he cranked out these beauties, “For? Against? I don’t know - I just like to protest stuff” “I was promised a free hat” and “Waffles are delicious!”

Even the president of the college Republicans, who was standing next to me at the time, had to agree, “Well,” he said, “I have to admit, waffles are delicious.”

Somewhere along the line, the protest turned into a party for those who only came for… well, I’m not sure why they came - maybe it was the nice weather. Three Woodstock wannabe girls punctuated that point by dancing barefoot through the crowd to The Who’s “We Don’t Get Fooled Again” (hardly the group, or the song I would associate with Republicans) that was blasting over the PA. And when tempers did flare between opposing sides, one student simply penned a sign that said, “Be Nicer!”

In my 15 years as a small-town boy covering protests in Ann Arbor, it was by far the oddest I’d seen to date. But in the end there was one thing I knew for sure: no matter what side of the issue, if any, the protestors chose, each and every protest sign there that day was 100 percent recyclable!

This is Ann Arbor, after all.

Lon Horwedel is a photojournalist for AnnArbor.com. You may contact him at lonhorwedel@annarbor.com.

Comments

Samuel Marvin

Tue, Apr 27, 2010 : 7:58 p.m.

As the proud owner of the "Bring Back Led Zeppelin" sign I would like to protest your assertion that it was "sloppy." Yes, it was handwritten, but the penmanship is excellent. Additionally, your article failed to mention the far more controversial reverse of my sign : "Obama, cancel Glee."

Annie Zirkel

Tue, Apr 27, 2010 : 9:08 a.m.

Great observations. Thanks for sharing and (and adding to) a bit of lightness - frankly we could use it. And I'm thinking that since good conflict resolution starts with remembering what we have in common - The waffle guy is on to something!

Anonymous Due to Bigotry

Mon, Apr 26, 2010 : 4:04 p.m.

If it's written on a sign that someone's carrying then it must be true.

Heather Heath Chapman

Mon, Apr 26, 2010 : 9:45 a.m.

This made me laugh--especially the puppies and the waffles. Thanks, Lon.