You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Sun, Dec 6, 2009 : 5:04 a.m.

Shortage of H1N1 flu vaccine shows urgent need to modernize our vaccination capacity

By Tony Dearing

If it were up to Washtenaw County health officials, there’d be enough H1N1 flu vaccine to go around. But there isn’t - here or anywhere else, for that matter.

Still, as serious and frustrating as the shortage of vaccine is, local health officials and the public both deserve credit for how well they’re coping with it.

H1N1 clinic.jpg

People wait in long lines at an H1N1 vaccination clinic at Pioneer High School last month.

If anything, problems with the supply and distribution of this particular vaccine have created a greater awareness of how vulnerable we’d all be in the face of a grave flu pandemic, which H1N1 fortunately is not.

H1N1 hasn’t proven to be more deadly than one would expect from a seasonal flu. However, this flu is particularly contagious, affects the young more than the elderly, and is unpredictable in how bad the complications can be for those who get it. For those reasons, H1N1 has gotten more media attention than other flu strains.

Such coverage feeds public anxiety. When vaccine is in short supply, it heightens the anxiousness and puts a difficult burden on the public health system to quickly and fairly distribute vaccine in a way that doesn’t lead to massive frustration or needless panic.


Links to more
H1N1 info

Visit the Web site of the Centers for Disease Control for extensive information on the H1N1 flu and vaccine

Find out who the priority groups are for vaccination

Follow these simple tips to reduce your risk of getting the flu

Send an e-mail to U.S. Sen. Carl Levin or U.S. Sen. Debbie Stabenow


Local health officials certainly aren’t to blame for the shortage. That’s a
worldwide issue, caused by a combination of bad fortune and a variety of inadequacies in the global production and distribution network. There are parts of the developing world where nobody has gotten the vaccine. And even in a country like ours, which is wealthy enough to buy its way into the front of the line, health officials overestimated and overpromised how much H1N1 vaccine would be available nationally.

In Michigan, it’s been estimated we’d need more than 5 million doses of vaccine to serve everyone who’s considered a priority risk for H1N1. The state’s been allotted 2.2 million doses. The math isn’t hard to do. Most people who want the vaccine aren’t going to get it.

At worst, the result can be a minor fiasco like the vaccination clinic that the county Health Department attempted at the Washtenaw Intermediate School District building in late October. The clinic was immediately swamped, snarling traffic on South Wagner Road and causing hundreds of people to be sent away unserved.

While that could have been avoided with better planning, we can’t fault county health officials for how quickly they regrouped and improved the process, adding more volunteers, choosing locations with better logistics and introducing a wristband system that evened out the flow of people waiting to be vaccinated. With these and other improvements, each subsequent clinic has gone better and earned mostly positive reviews from those who’ve been through the experience. Health officials also appreciate the spirit of patience and cooperation they’ve seen from the public.

Those who haven’t been vaccinated yet and want to be should watch for information on future clinics and go prepared to accept some inconvenience.

Meanwhile, the greater concern here is our demonstrated inability as a nation to provide adequate vaccine to those who need it. As U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius said last week, we are fighting current flu strains with technology from the 1950s. Should a more deadly flu come along, such as an avian flu outbreak that’s been predicted, the result would be a calamity.

On a federal level, we need immediate investment in a new domestic system for developing and delivering adequate vaccine to our country and others. Whether that comes as part of national health care reform, or out of a major review that Sebelius ordered this past week, efforts to modernize the system must begin now.

If you believe in prevention, then make sure to cover your mouth when you sneeze, wash your hands regularly with soap and water - and contact your U.S. senator or representative to demand that they act now to address the many shortcomings in our vaccination system that the current debacle has so clearly exposed.

Comments

Jan

Tue, Dec 8, 2009 : 8:33 a.m.

It wasn't any threat of lawsuit that delayed the manufacturing though. The ball was dropped when proper testing was delayed at the manufacturers. It was their inadequacy that delayed the supply.

Diagenes

Mon, Dec 7, 2009 : 10:44 p.m.

Jan, Clinton era regulations imposed on the vaccine makers have reduced overall supply of vaccines and reduced incentive to do the R & D neccesary to meet future needs. Along with the threat of lawsuits there is little financial incentive for big pharma to get into the vaccine business.

Jan

Sun, Dec 6, 2009 : 12:37 p.m.

Hillary has nothing to do with this problem. Get an updated clue; it'a almost 2010 now. "To really understand how much product you have, you need to do potency tests," says Dr. Anne Schuchat, chief of the CDC's National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases. She says reliable tests used to measure potency were delayed. "When they were run, the manufacturers basically found out that the product they had was actually less than they thought they had," Schuchat said in an interview with NPR. "That wasn't something we knew a long time ago. That's relatively recent."

Technojunkie

Sun, Dec 6, 2009 : 10:13 a.m.

Hillary Clinton's price controls and legal terrorism by trial lawyers destroyed most of the vaccine production infrastructure and the damage was never undone. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10709334579624100.html That's from 2003, commenting on the 1993 Vaccines for Children program. More detail from 2005: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB112993509813676199-email.html

Connie

Sun, Dec 6, 2009 : 6:21 a.m.

Thank you for supporting the local public health department.