Vote Yes: Millage needed to keep strong school system
As business people in the Ann Arbor community, we are writing this letter to show our firm support of the proposed Washtenaw Schools Millage proposal that will come to voters on Nov. 3. We strongly urge you to vote yes.
As business people in the Ann Arbor community, we are writing this letter to show our firm support of the proposed Washtenaw Schools Millage proposal that will come to voters on Nov. 3. We strongly urge you to vote yes.
No one wants a tax increase, especially at this time when, as a state and region, we face significant economic challenges. However, this millage is our only path for replacing the devastating state funding reductions in school aid this year and over the next several years - which are severely deeper than anyone expected.
State of Michigan funding for education is legislatively determined. To change the funding model requires legislative reform, which we strongly support. But we can’t afford to wait for this to occur. If we don’t act now, our schools will suffer permanent damage and so will the economic vitality of our community.
The Intermediate School District millage legislatively provides the only option under the current state funding model to supplement operating revenue. By law, up to 3 mills can be levied subject to voter support but the districts making up the Washtenaw Intermediate School District (WISD) chose to do only 2 mills at this time. They are unanimous in their request for this millage.
Ann Arbor Public Schools, and the other county districts, foresaw - and prepared for -- this cliff in state funding. This millage is a proactive approach to making sure our schools stay adequately funded while the state sorts out its financial crisis. In addition, Ann Arbor has reduced its annual budget by $16 million over the past four years. The other area school districts have made similar cuts in their operating budgets before approaching voters in our community.
With the excellent leadership of Supt. Todd Roberts, Ann Arbor Public Schools has managed its finances responsibly and with foresight. In healthcare, the district has reduced the annual increase over the past five years to about 1.5 percent vs. a national increase on average in healthcare costs of 7 percent per year and in Michigan, on average 4 percent per year. Employees are contributing more toward their healthcare costs and the district has capped the amount it contributes to healthcare. Local school districts have no control over retirement benefit costs, which are determined by the state (the retirement program is a defined benefit plan over which the district has no control).
Ann Arbor has made substantial cost cuts but our state funding crisis can only be solved with added revenue. Annual operating revenue has increased about 1.5 percent per year over the past five years while operating costs have increased about 5 percent per year. In fact, in Ann Arbor, we pay 45 percent less in education-related homestead taxes than we did in 1994. The millage is the only option available to raise revenue.
Strong schools are critical to a robust community. They attract families to the area as well as provide companies an incentive to locate their businesses here. According to a 2009 study (Cyberhomes), median home sale prices in zip codes with very high-rated schools, as ranked by GreatSchools, were 62 percent higher than those in zip codes with average schools and 92 percent higher than those with low-rated schools. Zip codes with top notch schools enjoy a 31 percent premium over the market. Kalamazoo is one of three other communities in Michigan which has passed a similar millage. Kalamazoo has become a benchmark in economic development by strengthening their schools and continuing to attract new businesses to the area despite a failing economy.
If we don’t pass the millage, those very elements that have earned the Ann Arbor Public Schools recognition will be at risk - Grammy awards for a strong music program, student performance well above the state average in many achievement measures, early childhood initiatives to diminish the level of literacy deficiency, sports programs and elementary libraries. Loss of teachers would result in class size increase and less personal attention at the elementary level, just where studies show it’s critical. Consolidating schools runs the risk of losing pupils to private schools resulting in additional revenue losses.
Strong schools are the heart and engine of a strong community. They prepare our children and grandchildren for the 21st century realities. They attract companies and families to the area. We must act locally to help our schools stay strong. The millage is our only option. Please join us in voting yes on Nov. 3 and help keep our community vital and economically strong.
- Norman Herbert, Bob Chapman, Paul Saginaw & Rich Sheridan
Comments
Gold
Fri, Jan 8, 2010 : 4:26 a.m.
I admire writer that wrote remarkable articles that are really useful to the readers and bloggers like me for you teaches many lessons and provide endless useful information. Hope to read more from you guys and Thanks a lot for the post! I look forward for your next post. Small Business Loans
Gold
Fri, Jan 8, 2010 : 3:47 a.m.
I really love reading posts that has lots of knowledge to impart. I admire those writers who share the best of their knowledge in writing such articles. Keep up the good work and continue inspiring readers.Thank you so much. Regards, Hydroponics Wholesale
Thu, Oct 29, 2009 : 11:36 p.m.
"in Ann Arbor, we pay 45 percent less in education-related homestead taxes than we did in 1994" or "Currently, we only have 7.4 mills on homestead property tax both stated on the Citizen Millage Committee literature. A BIG "LITTLE WHITE LIE". I don't know about your property tax bill, but on my bill I pay 17.52 mills in education-related property taxes. Yes, perhaps the AAPS only collects 7.4 mills directly, but you forget the 2 WISD millages and the State Education Tax that is also collected for a total of 17.52 mills, a lot higher than your 7.4. The WISD mills are then passed through to local districts to cover federally mandated special education services, etc, and the AAPS also gets the state ed money. So your 45% decrease looks like funny math to me. It looks more like a 30% increase, not a decrease. If we add the 2 additional mills the district is asking for, up to 19.52, thats a 45% increase since 1974. And dont forget, the property tax relief that was part of Proposal A, also came with a sales tax increase of 2 cents, from 4 cents to 6 cents. So do not imply that we are better off now, paying less in education-related property tax now than we were in 1994. NOT TRUE! PS: Isn't Norman Herbert a paid consultant with the Ann Arbor Public Schools??
DonBee
Thu, Oct 29, 2009 : 8:55 p.m.
Fortunately this is not the only way to fix the cuts, if you were listening to Michigan Radio today, you know that both the House and the Senate took up efforts to override the Governor's Veto today. It is not the crisis some people want it to be. The veto has a high probablity of being overridden. That does not solve the funding issue, but it does take the "pass this now or your children will suffer" issue off the table. We need a school board that will go through the overhead with a fine tooth comb in Ann Arbor. We need Ypsi, Willow Run and Lincoln to merge. Remember if you pass this - -Some of it will go to out of county students. -No Charter school will see a nickel, not even the Washtenaw Techical Middle College (the collaboration between AAPS and WCC). That is 3500 public school children that will get no support. -That if you live in Ann Arbor about 30% of what you pay in taxes will go to a different district in the county.
aataxpayer
Thu, Oct 29, 2009 : 3:37 p.m.
Tom, State law does not allow the enhancement money to include charter schools. We need many reforms in state law to fix problems, but Sen Brater and Rep Warren are among those are unwilling to oppose the MEA and do what is really needed.
Tom Bower
Thu, Oct 29, 2009 : 1:38 p.m.
What about the 3,500 students attending public school academies in Washtenaw County? Oh, I guess they are not as important as students attending the ten "general powers" school districts.