You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 5:58 a.m.

Parents object to Ann Arbor busing plan, but officials stand firm for now

By Tom Perkins

More than 70 parents met with several Ann Arbor Public Schools officials Tuesday night to express their unhappiness with a new busing plan, but administrators made clear they're making no changes before school starts.

In an effort to reduce transportation costs, the district created “common stops” and cut the number of bus stops at the high school level from 60 to 30. That means students in the Arrowwood Hills Cooperative will have to walk nearly a mile to the nearest common stop, which is at Northside Elementary School, to catch the bus to Skyline High School or another school destination.

About half the parents at the meeting Thursday night represented students from Arrowwood and another half represented those from the Foxfire Subdivision who attend Logan Elementary. Several other parents representing children from various schools around the district were also present.

The parents are asking district officials to place another stop in their respective neighborhoods because of concerns about their children walking a mile down roads like Pontiac Trail or Dhu Varren Road to get to stops or school.


Many students will have to walk or get a ride to common bus stops in the Ann Arbor school district this year.

Jeffrey Smith | For

But straightaway, officials made clear that no routes or busing schedules would change before school starts on Sept. 6. Instead, there will be a two-week assessment period in which administration, drivers and supervisors will focus on problem spots. Administration will then make a recommendation on any changes to the school board on Sept. 21.

“If we see something comes up and it, for lack of a better word, becomes an emergency situation we will correct that,” said Robert Allen, the district’s director of operations.

The new busing routes are part of a plan to reduce $15 million from the budget this year. The transportation changes account for around $1.3 million of those cuts.

District Spokeswoman Liz Margolis said the plan originally called for the elimination of all high school transportation, but the district transferred $300,000 out of its fund equity to allow for some busing.

“Frankly, we have to cut in a lot of areas where we aren’t pleased we have to cut, and one of those is in transportation,” she said.

Students at the elementary and middle school level who live within 1.5 miles of their school will no longer have regular bus service and be required to walk to school or go to common stops, unless the district finds a special safety concern. All high school students will have to walk to common stops or directly to the school or provide their own transportation.

Tom Moore is director of transportation for the Washtenaw Intermediate School District. Ann Arbor schools contract with WISD to provide transportation. He explained in some cases, parents live more than two miles from the nearest common stop. In those cases, the common stops are intended as “drop off and pick up zones” for parents to drop off students to catch the bus, he said.

He also said per Michigan law, the school district is not responsible for the students until they board the bus. He said parents are responsible for their safety on the walk to the bus stop and while waiting at the stop.

Officials said common stops' locations were determined by assessing population densities in different areas and the safety of the stop where children would be picked up.

Moore explained “safe routes” for students to walk to common stops have sidewalks along main roads and crosswalks or lighted intersections for crossing the main roads. He said subdivisions where speed limits are 25 mph or less and there are no sidewalks are not considered a safety hazard.

Dozens of parents spoke during a question-and-answer session, and many expressed concerns over specific roads where they said there wasn’t adequate lighting or sidewalks. They said under the plan, their children would be walking up to 45 minutes in the dark and snow during winter months. Several invited officials to make those walks with a book bag on their backs.

Kaaronica Evansware who lives in Firefox and has a child at Logan, said the budget savings aren't worth the risk.

“Our risk is our children’s ... well being,” she said. “If one of our girls is raped, if one of our kids is kidnapped, $15 million (in money saved through cuts) is not enough to award a parent for one of their kids' lives.”

James Anderson is a parent of three children who will be affected at three different schools. He asked why the WISD never consulted the parents when developing plans for common stops. He contended parents are most familiar with the routes students will walk and possible dangers .

“We know better than you where those common stops should be,” he said. “Did anyone ask people most affected?”

Several students and parents also pointed out that students would have to wake up much earlier than before to walk to the common stop and catch a bus to their destination school.

“If you are thinking about achievement gap, this isn’t going to help,” said Ann Carrellas, who lives in Arrowwood and has a daughter attending Skyline. “Kids are going to be tired, they aren’t going to be focused.”

Jeri Schneider is also a mother of a Skyline student and lives in Arrowwood. She said there are a handful of neighborhoods where parents are asking for a bus stop and told officials she didn’t believe it would cost much more to have them.

“Why can’t we do these few additional stops?” she asked. “It’s just a little bit of extra time and a little bit of extra gas.”

When directly asked how much it would cost to add an additional stop, officials said they did not know.

“We will evaluate that,” Moore said.

Several parents said they wanted the school board to hold a special meeting on the issue. Three board members are needed to support a special meeting and board Vice President Susan Baskett and Trustee Simone Lightfoot were present. They told parents to write and call other board members and urge them to call a special meeting.


Ahmar Iqbal

Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 11:43 a.m.

The school board and school administration have "fumbled" again. Whether it was sharing elementary school principals, cutting freshman sports and initially cutting all high school busing, there is a disconnect between the school board and administration with the community, especially the parents. Yesterday at the meeting, WISD Transportation Director stated that average cost of a bus run is $50 for morning and $50 for afternoon. If the same bus, makes a couple of extra stops, perhaps the daily cost is $5 or $10 more. The extra cost maybe the additional gas, driver's time perhaps an extra turn or two. Even at $10 per day and 180 school days, we are talking about $1,800 for the whole year to add a couple of more bus stops. Considering the "community" cost of each parents' fuel, carbon footprint and pollution, extra traffic, etc. it seems a couple of extra stops is the solution. The overall point is that the school administration makes decisions in a very isolated manner and then waits for any reaction to see if it needs "adjustment." If feedback had been received prior to finalizing these bus stops, then we could have avoided this going back and forth. Energy and community capital would not have been wasted. Certainly, there are new subdivisions that were not planned when the elementary schools were built and hence, walking to school was more convenient 20-30 years ago when the schools were constructed around those homes. Moreover, safety is a concern especially for 6 ?7 ? 8 year olds to walk across hilly roads where posted speed limits of 35 mph are often ignored. I hope no one gets hurt before an easy, common sense solution is reached.


Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 11:25 a.m.

walking is good for you. it will not harm kids. just funny that it looks like rich kids dont have to walk.


Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 11:21 a.m.

Before anyone begins by saying A2 parents are helicopter, spoilt, privileged, etc. I would wish to point out an obvious flaw in the decisions by the Ann Arbor Board of Education's decision of the 1.5 mile walking distance for elementary schools. 1.5 miles would be fine if the weather were perfect. That is the case in Florida. In Wisconsin and Minnesota, the walk zone is 0.5 miles. Ann Arbor's winters cannot be compared with Florida's. BOE- can you really justify having 6- & 7-year olds walk through snow and ice, and through woods where much of the sidewalks are not plowed? I challenge any of you to do it.


Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 11:41 a.m.

re: lynel - This isn't about 6 & 7 year olds, it's about high school students. You are wrong, Lynel. This is also about elementary students who live within 1.5 miles of the school. My 5 year old Kindergartner is now going walk 0.4 miles and cross a relatively busy road outside of our neighborhood because of these changes.


Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 11:31 a.m.

This isn't about 6 & 7 year olds, it's about high school students.