You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Thu, Jul 22, 2010 : 4:44 p.m.

Scores trend slightly upward for most Washtenaw County school districts on MME, ACT

By David Jesse

In Saline, like many other school districts in Washtenaw County, today's release of Michigan Merit Exam and ACT test scores for the just completed school year is a time for celebration.

“We’re very proud of our students,” Superintendent Scot Graden said. “Our staff is doing a great job to make sure students are well-prepared for whatever is next for them, whether it’s college or something else. Our community is very supportive of quality education.”

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Scot_Graden2.JPG

Saline Superintendent Scot Graden

Saline isn't alone. Results released today show seven of the 13 districts or charter schools in Washtenaw County scored above the state mean ACT composite score.

Saline saw growth in four of the five areas tested on the MME and in six of the seven categories on the ACT when comparing the 2010 test results with the 2009 test results. Saline also had the highest mean ACT composite score of any district in the county.

But Graden says Saline wants to do even better.

“At times, it can be hard to develop a sense of urgency when our scores are high,” Graden said. “You can walk into a meeting about improving our education and in the back of your mind is, ‘we already have good scores.’”

Graden wants the lessons taught by Saline’s teachers to stick around longer than for a test. That’s why he and the district are focusing on project-based learning and using technology, among other approaches.

“That is paying off in these standardized tests," he said. "None of these are at a hundred. We can still improve. It’s a growth model. We want to be growing.”

Across the county, districts as a whole and individual high schools saw increases in 41 categories on the MME, while they saw decreases in 46 categories.

Beyond continued growth in the overall scores, there are always individual students to worry about, Ann Arbor Superintendent Todd Roberts said.

That’s not just for students who are struggling. The district looks at the students who scored as proficient and then at how many of those fall into the advanced proficient category. Getting into the advanced category is a good predictor of success down the road, Roberts said.

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for toddroberts101809.jpg

Ann Arbor Superintendent Todd Roberts

Ann Arbor had increases in three of the five MME categories and five of the seven ACT categories. The district had the second-highest mean ACT composite score, just 0.4 off Saline's score.

Roberts said he’s encouraged by the results, particularly as he looks at the lowest-performing students in the district.

“The groups that are the lowest made the most progress,” he said.

That can be seen even at the Roberto Clemente Student Development Center, traditionally the lowest performing of the district’s high schools. The percentage of students ranking as proficient jumped nearly 15 percentage points in math and nearly 11 points in social studies.

It wasn't a success story in every local school district.

The Lincoln school district saw declines in every category on both the MME and ACT.

But Superintendent Lynn Cleary said those numbers aren't accurate.

"We have an appeal in place," she said. "We were told that our students that are attending the Early College Alliance would have their scores sent back to us. It looks like about 40 of our students who attend the ECA weren't included. That's almost 10 percent of our students."

Cleary said district officials will be working hard on the issue in the coming days to get clarification.

Ypsilanti also saw drops in multiple categories. The district was at least 17 percentage points under the state average in every category on the MME, including being just over 29 percentage points lower than the state average in science.

“We are aggressively devising instructional reforms for fall that will increase the rigor of our courses to align with the common standards recently adopted by the Michigan Department of Education,” said Jennifer Martin, assistant superintendent of educational quality. “Low student performance is unacceptable, and I’m confident there will be different results in the future.”

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Dedrick Martin.jpg

Ypsilanti Superintendent Dedrick Martin

Superintendent Dedrick Martin agreed.

“We have identified several internal deficiencies at the secondary level, and Jennifer Martin continues to move forward with a restructuring plan," he said. "She has been meeting with administrators, building level leaders, teachers, parents and students to prepare a fall implementation that will raise expectations for teaching and learning. Over the summer, we have also been meeting with our university partners and have secured a renewed commitment to engage students in the learning process resulting in greater achievement.”

Across the state, scores for Michigan high school students kept improving in most subjects, state officials said, a trend they attribute to the state's tougher graduation requirements.

Public school scores on the Michigan Merit Exam improved in math, science, reading and writing. The percentage of students scoring proficient or better in those subjects is the highest in the four-year history of the exam.

Scores declined in social studies.

The tests were taken in the spring, primarily by last academic year's high school juniors. They are the first students who will be required by law to meet the more stringent graduation standards approved by the Legislature four years ago. The standards include more mandatory math and science classes.

David Jesse covers K-12 education for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at davidjesse@annarbor.com or at 734-623-2534.

Comments

teacher

Sat, Jul 31, 2010 : 1:01 p.m.

There are several schools in the county that have students attending ECA. Most likely many of those students are high achieving students. They are entering a program to take college level classes while they are still in high school. The article was comparing how districts are preparing students for success on the MME test. If the ECA test scores were not included in each participating school district, I believe it is a fair comparison to look and compare the district level data. The article was discussing how each district was working to improve student scores. It would be interesting to see how the ECA group as a whole compared to the district level county data. The issue of high numbers of at risk and underachieving students is a different issue. Lincoln is not the only school district in Washtenaw County serving at risk students. It is not the only school district with data that is impacted by serving a high number of at risk students. Meeting the needs of the county's most at risk students is challenging. MME data does not always give a clear picture of the growth that students are making but it is the yardstick that is used to measure school district success. Many of the school districts with the highest test scores are not serving a high percentage of at risk students. It would seem that ECA has placed Lincoln School district in a situation that is similar to neighboring districts. Higher achieving students are leaving for other educational opportunities and the district is left to meet the needs of the remaining students who may require changes in instruction and additional support to make growth. This situation is a challenging and complex situation. The benefit of the ECA program is that higher achieving students can leave their home district to meet their educational needs without causing a financial crisis in their home district with their departure.

ypsineighbor

Wed, Jul 28, 2010 : 9:38 p.m.

Yes those students get most of their instruction from EMU. However, Lincoln contributes many more students to ECA than any other District. And from what I've seen, the students who participate in ECA are at the upper end of the test achievement scale. So when you have a big chunk of your higher achievers in ECA, comparing Lincoln's data to everyone else's data in an article like is not a fair comparison.

teacher

Tue, Jul 27, 2010 : 2:18 p.m.

I'm not sure why the ECA scores should be reflected in the Lincoln data or any other district's data. After 9th grade, ECA students receive their instruction through classes at EMU. Putting ECA scores in with district data does not give an accurate picture of district level growth. ECA scores are a better indicator of what EMU is doing not the home district. It would seem that Lincoln's time and resources would be better spent focusing on what to do with the students who do remain within their district receiving instruction and how those students can be supported in ways that will allow them to make growth and be successful which in turn would improve the district data.

ypsineighbor

Sun, Jul 25, 2010 : 8:31 a.m.

Why were the ECA scores split out from participating schools? By doing that, you are comparing apples to oranges. It's unfair to simply cite Lincoln's test scores relative to other Washtenaw districts without explaining the whole picture.

DagnyJ

Fri, Jul 23, 2010 : 10:21 a.m.

Thank you Todd Roberts for pointing out that raising the scores of the most challenged students is more important that cheering the top scores of the rich and elite.

lovelincoln

Fri, Jul 23, 2010 : 7:24 a.m.

For those not familiar with the Early College Alliance, some of the brightest students spend their days taking college courses. It sounds like these students test scores werent included in Lincolns numbers.

tmad40blue

Fri, Jul 23, 2010 : 6:26 a.m.

See? We students aren't useless; we can actually accomplish something.

old65

Fri, Jul 23, 2010 : 6:25 a.m.

A mistake has been made in Lincoln's scores as they are one of "Michigan's Best Schools"

AlphaAlpha

Thu, Jul 22, 2010 : 10:15 p.m.

"Across the county, districts as a whole and individual high schools saw increases in 41 categories on the MME, while they saw decreases in 46 categories." Wouldn't that suggest the trend was slightly down?