Willow Run and Ypsilanti school boards take step toward more consolidation at joint meeting
Not much actual policy-making was done at Wednesday’s joint meeting of the Ypsilanti and Willow Run boards of education, but both boards signaled their intent to create a different environment for area students.
The only voting during the meeting came to approve a joint task force for collaboration and communication between the two districts and to appoint 2 representatives from each board to serve on the task force.
However, the showing of local political figures and school officials underscored the interest both districts have in moving toward consolidating services between them.
The joint task force will explore opportunities to share services and resources between the 2 school districts during the 2011-12 school year. The immediate areas the task force will look at are moving toward a common software platform and consolidation in human resources, career and technical education and business services.
“We’re not together, but we’re in the same city, so I see it as a positive thing for Ypsilanti and Willow Run to work together,” said Don Garrett, president of the Willow Run school board. “We’ve taken better steps to ensure a better education for our kids and for Ypsilanti as a whole.”
Trustees Ellen Champagne and Kira Berman will serve on the task force as the Ypsilanti school board representatives and Kristine Thomas and Gregory Myers will serve as the Willow Run school board representatives. The appointments last through the 2011-12 school year.
The meeting was the culmination of a process that began in the spring, when Ypsilanti school board President David Bates approached Garrett about having a meeting of the 2 school boards. The presidents met several times throughout the summer, along with officials from the Washtenaw Intermediate School District, to set out details for the meeting and to discuss what could be accomplished.
Ypsilanti and Willow Run find themselves in similar positions — both districts have their high schools on the list of persistently lowest achieving schools and are among the 23 school districts that have a deficit of more than $1 million in their fund balance. Having that deficit opens the possibility for both districts to be taken over by a financial manager.
Bates recognized that fact when he paraphrased a quote from Benjamin Franklin.
“Given the circumstances, either we’re going to find a way to hang together and work together or we’re going to hang separately,” he said.
The meeting took place at Eastern Michigan University’s Welch Hall in the room usually reserved for EMU Board of Regents meetings. While there were plenty of parents in attendance, many elected officials were in attendance as well to give their stamp of approval on the new task force.
Among those in attendance were Washtenaw County Commissioners Rolland Sizemore, Dan Smith and Ronnie Peterson, all of whom implored the school boards to utilize opportunities to allow students to work with the county government to gain apprenticeship experience on various projects.
State Rep. David Rutledge, D-Superior Township, played a major role in bringing the two school boards together and has worked closely with both Ypsilanti Superintendent Dedrick Martin and Willow Run Superintendent Laura Lisiscki. The new joint task force will report to Rutledge and both school boards quarterly.
Rutledge showed off a shirt he wore underneath his jacket and dress shirt that read “Exploring The Best of Both Worlds” and told the school boards, “I’m going to wear this until we get something done.”
He said he hoped "this gets us to think more regionally'' rather than thinking in terms of school districts. “I hope we pull others into that mindset,'' he said. "I think that what you do now and the steps you take now will set the tone and set the model that could be duplicated across the state.”
While the school districts do intend to work more closely together, there was no indication that school officials intend to consolidate the districts into one larger district. Both Martin and Lisiscki said they believed the time was right to start looking across district lines in a bigger way, after joining programs like the Early College Alliance, WISD busing consortium, Widening Advancements for Youth program and Washtenaw International High School in recent years.
“I’m very excited about the opportunity to work with our neighbors and I believe it is the right time to collaborate and provide the best services for eastern Washtenaw kids,” Lisiscki said. “This is the first step for both communities to enhance not only student achievement, but to serve the greater Ypsilanti area. We’re on the right track.”
Kyle Feldscher covers police and courts for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at kylefeldscher@annarbor.com or you can follow him on Twitter.
Comments
Bill
Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 5:04 p.m.
I think we need to give both boards some time to develop a plan to consolidate services and ultimately the two districts. It is easy to go back to the past and look at the failures, but times have changed and there are new individuals on Boards that may truly want to make a difference. There are far too many school districts in this area with too few students in each district. Having worked in another state with a district that was several times larger than these districts and geographically covered the equivalent of one entire county, I know it is possible to provide a quality local education even with a centralized admininstrative staff and support services. It is better for the local districts to develop their own plan and become financially solvent than to have the governor appoint a financial manager to do it for them.
tom swift jr.
Fri, Aug 26, 2011 : 2:14 a.m.
This is a positive move... the consolidation will take time. Congratulations to both Boards for taking this step.
apples
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 8:52 p.m.
Good luck to Ypsi&,Willow Run I see great things ahead for the students.Keep on working together and keep the needs of the students first. It's imperative for all students to have the best quality education possible Change is necessary and possible and I look forward to higher student achievement for all students
jns131
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 3:06 p.m.
From an email I got I was told that both school districts are going to face a state mandate manager, like Detroit unless things improve dramatically. I was also told and now I am reading it here, that they are considering consolidating which, like Lincoln Consolidated, could become Ypsilanti Consolidated if approved before the end of this school year next June. I really see this happening and if it does happen? Then I also foresee WISD being shoved out of the transportation business and either consolidating it themselves or bringing in Trinity full time. Guess what Ann Arbor, WISD is now your problem. But then again Ann Arbor is creating its own problems. I really see this happening becoming something much bigger in a year or so. Congrats on a well planned team WR and Ypsi. Thank you Ypsilanti and Willow Run for teaming up against Ann Arbor. Like Plymouth Canton, I can see good things happening out of this.
bgrant
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 12:32 p.m.
Grapes Juicey: Granted the YPS closed schools before WR, but consider the following: WR Suffered a deficit (negative cash balance) in 1986, and did not close schools to economize. YPS suffered a deficit in 1992 and closed schools to economize. WR again suffered a deficit in approximately 2006? ( I may be off a year give or take), but refused to close schools to economize. Yps again suffered a deficit on 2009 and closed schools to economize WR spent bond money on schools which should have been closed due to low enrollment. For years after the schools were not filled to capacity (my opinion) The sad case for both districts is that charter schools popped up all around, and enrollment in both districts lost students. I would like nothing more than to see both districts consolidate, in order to keep alive. I have empathy for bot districts. Check the true history... I was there
slave2work
Mon, Aug 29, 2011 : 2:16 a.m.
bet you went to ypsi
Grapes Juicey
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 11:51 a.m.
Wonder if the poor economy can be blamed for the pessimistic perspectives on display here? It may be true that WR started to lose students when school of choice was enacted. However, the mere FACT that YPS started closing schools long before WR did, leads me to believe that they didn't leave WR to head to YPS. In FACT YPS closed 2 elementary schools before WR even closed one. Also the FACT that this meeting even took place is PROOF that there has been some change. As well as the FACT that they have consolidated transportation services and are collaborating on the WAY Program, Early College Alliance, etc.. proves that it's not just talk and that there has been some change. The FACT is that both schools, along with many others in Wash Cty, are at risk of being taken over by a financial manager. Neither district wants that and they have taken positive steps towards preventing it. Only time will tell what the outcome will be, but I am hopeful that there will continue to be a WRCS and YPS that works collaboratively on whatever they can. We must first be responsible for educating ourselves, before we can begin to educate anyone else. Get the FACTS straight!
bgrant
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 11:23 a.m.
Bob: Class realist.....
bgrant
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 10:50 a.m.
Willow Run has always tried and failed to be competitive towards Ypsilanti. When Ypsilanti started "Open Enrollment", families left Willow Run in droves to attend Ypsilanti, based upon the belief that that they would receive a better education. The enrollment continued to decline in Willow Run. With this rocky relationship in the past , there will never be true cooperation with Ypsilanti because of the fear of being swallowed up into a consolidated school district.
Bob
Thu, Aug 25, 2011 : 11:16 a.m.
So, I'm guessing you weren't class optomist . . .