You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 1 p.m.

Eastern Michigan self-reports 4 major NCAA violations in women's basketball program, suspends coach, punishes others

By Jeff Arnold


Eastern Michigan women's basketball coach AnnMarie Gilbert is suspended one month as part of the university's self-imposed sanctions after self-reporting four violations to the NCAA.

File photo

A 2009-10 season that included a trip to the Women’s National Invitation Tournament for the Eastern Michigan University's women's basketball team also involved four major NCAA violations, university officials announced Monday.

The university self-reported four major violations to the NCAA and suspended head coach AnnMarie Gilbert for a month without pay. Several other assistant coaches received letters of reprimand and one is suspended indefinitely. Eastern Michigan assistant coach LaTonya Tate was named acting head coach during Gilbert's suspension.

Other than an acknowledgment it has received the self-report, no communication has been received from the NCAA about the alleged violations, Eastern Michigan President Susan Martin said in a press conference on Monday.

The bulk of the violations concern practice hours at Eastern, which was 22-9 overall last season, 11-5 in the Mid-American Conference. The Eagles won the Mid-American Conference West Division title in her first season after being hired by Gragg to replace Suzy Merchant, who is now the head coach at Michigan State.

Gilbert, whose suspension began Monday, is a former Michigan State assistant coach. Eastern Michigan athletic director Derrick Gragg said Gilbert was remorseful about the violations taking place.

According to the university's report to the NCAA, practices exceeded the daily four-hour limit, sometimes lasting as long as six hours if players watched film. Gilbert, who did not return a phone call seeking comment Monday morning, told university officials she was under the impression that countable hours did not begin until actual skill instruction began.

Players, who were interviewed individually by Eastern Michigan compliance officers, said they routinely arrived at practice at 1:15 p.m. By the time practice, conditioning and film study ended, players told university officials that it was often 7:30 or 8 p.m. before they left.

The report also indicates that evidence suggests that players were instructed to lie by Eastern Michigan assistant coach Darin Thrun once coaches learned compliance officials were examining team practices.

The report states that players were told Thrun would be fired if the truth came out as to how long they had practiced. Thrun reportedly told players to tell compliance officers they practiced two hours and to tell them, "this, this and this." Players were also told to tell officials that they had not watched film or worked out.

Players said they felt like they had been "put in the middle." and told school officials they wanted to tell the truth, but were allegedly by Thrun that if they told the truth, he would be fired.

The investigation began in late July, when an Eastern Michigan player came to the athletic department with complaints about excessive practice, Gragg said. Gragg declined to specify whether the player was currently on the roster.

Gragg said he initiated the internal investigation based on the complaint of the player, saying the university always takes such concerns seriously.

"Anytime you get news like this as an athletic director, you're shocked," Gragg said.

Players were interviewed separately, as were the coaches, and Gilbert was talked to multiple times. Gilbert was interviewed on four occasions, stating in her third interview that she had time to reflect on information she had given previously. She told Gragg she did not understand when countable hours began.

The university found that while the basketball team filled out required forms counting practice hours, the times listed were not accurate, Gragg said.

The investigation found that players practiced during the summer, recruits took part in open gyms and other activities that are not allowed and that "the coaching staff arranged for prospective student-athletes visiting campus to participate in open gyms with current student-athletes and observed their participation" and improper participation by coaches in practices outside of the season.

The athletic department's investigation did not find any instances of EMU's compliance program not working. Gragg said Monday he believed the incident was isolated and that the overage of hours were limited to last season.

"I feel comfortable that the policies and the system are working," Gragg, a former compliance officer himself, said. "This is one of the strongest compliance systems I've been around."

Once the university had the results of the investigation, they took action, Martin said.

“We have taken swift and decisive action in this matter,” she said. “We demand the best of ourselves. We are full committed to the rules and policies of the NCAA.”

The biggest punishment comes in terms of the number of hours the team will be allowed to practice. The self-imposed sanctions will dock the team six hours a week during the fall and by five hours a week this winter.

Gragg said they followed the NCAA’s normal course of action of docking two hours of time for every hour a team was over. Gragg said a post-season ban was never considered.

In addition, the team was placed on probation for two years.

The school will reduce the number of expense-paid recruiting visits from 12 per year to 10 for the next two years. The university also closed recreational/open gym activities for prospects for the next two years.

Thrun has been suspended indefinitely with pay and has, like Gilbert, had his salary frozen for the remainder of the academic year.

Eastern Michigan officials set up a Web site to release information about the violations and university spokesman Walter Kraft said that site would be updated as events happened.

• Download a pdf of Eastern's internal investigation report: NCAA-internal-report.pdf • Download a pdf of AnnMarie Gilbert's letter of reprimand: NCAA-violations_Gilbert.pdf reporter David Jesse contributed to the story. Jeff Arnold covers sports for He can be reached at 734-623-2554 or by e-mail at Follow him on Twitter @jeffreyparnold.



Tue, Sep 28, 2010 : 8:19 a.m.

To be honest, this isn't the first time I have heard of rules violation coming from the women's basketball program at EMU since Ann Marie Gilbert started at Eastern and I am surprised it took this long for a student to come forward to report the issue. I'm glad the student had the guts to do it. NCAA Rules are there for a reason.


Tue, Sep 28, 2010 : 4:52 a.m.

"The investigation began in late July, when an Eastern Michigan player came to the athletic department with complaints about excessive practice, Gragg said. Gragg declined to specify whether the player was currently on the roster." The student reported the violation. She felt it was wrong and reported it. Good character. Brave student. But also important is the fact that the student reported it to the school! She clearly felt that EMU would do the right thing. She didn't run to the media. She didn't feel the need to go over the head of the EMU administrators. And, her faith was rewarded by EMU self-reporting and punishing the coaches involved. I'm very proud of the turnaround EMU has made over the past five years...from an administration that hid things and kept horrible secrets, to an administration that is open and honest and acts accordingly. Thanks EMU. I'm proud of you. Adversity will happen. It's how you deal with it that defines your institution.


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 9:34 p.m.

Ghost you can not even compare to Rich Rod. EMU practiced more in a day or two than Rich Rod did in an entire season. Sounds like up to 4 hours extra per day. RR had 20 minutes in an entire week. You try keeping that close of time with an activity involving 120 18 to 23 year olds. Lucky to come within 15 to 20 minutes. It does make me understand more of why Bo would lock the door at the start of practice and go. If you were late you missed it. With limited time and that many kids all you can do is lock the door and start right on time.


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 8:48 p.m.

i mean the program did have a somewhat successful year as far as EMU athletics go...just saying. Maybe that extra hours paid off. hahaha


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 3:33 p.m.

Sad but true. Here I was hoping for better from Ann. I saw some of this when at the REC/Im I was wondering if it was a rules violation or not at least 3 time that I can remember.

Elaine F. Owsley

Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 3:15 p.m.

It hardly seems fair that the person who told everyone to lie about the situation is still being paid and the coach is not. What criteria or degree of guilt does the University place on these folks?

thomas h blaske

Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 2:23 p.m.

If what the story says Thrun did (i.e. asked players to lie) is true he should be fired. EMU deserves better.


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 12:52 p.m. I give EMU a lot of credit for the public disciplinary actions. They are making a full public disclosure of the punishment. And it seems that they included the coach! This is the right thing to do to: 1. Regain confidence 2. Demonstrate commitment to playing by the rules


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 11:59 a.m.

wow! I guess this kind of thing does happen everywhere. 6 and 7 hours of practice, film, conditioning, stretching, or whatever is ridiculous if it is true.


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 11:53 a.m.

Mr Ghost.... kind of a cheap shot that does not befit your stature in other commentaries.


Mon, Sep 27, 2010 : 11:35 a.m.

Walking in Suzy Merchant's diminutive shadow is, apparently, a tall order. Hurons, Hurons, hats off to you.