You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Tue, Sep 22, 2009 : 1:53 p.m.

Scouting Ahead: A look at Indiana against Western Michigan

By Michael Rothstein

Welcome to "Scouting Ahead," a scouting report on Michigan's next opponent (when there is TV footage available).

For Indiana, I watched the Hoosiers' game against Western Michigan a couple weeks ago, a 23-19 win for Indiana. I tracked the first half of the game, both offensively and defensively.

NOTE: Darius Willis, the usual No. 2 back, missed this game due to an ankle injury.

OFFENSE PLAY-BY-PLAY: FIRST SCORING SERIES (DVR started at 12:22 left in first half): -Mitchell Evans run up the middle inside Western’s red zone. -2-4 pistol, 3 WR. Demetrius McCray runs right. Western defense lets him go nowhere. -3-4 pistol 3 WR Ben Chappell over middle to Terrance Turner for first down on an underneath route. -1-10 pistol 2 WR McCray run right. Had a nice hole. Good block by TE Troy Wagner -2-GL 1 WR left pistol Trea Burgess run middle. Crushed by Western line at line of scrimmage. Not much push by Indiana’s offensive line. 3-GL 3 WR pistol Chappell throws to the end zone for Damario Belcher, broken up on jump ball fade route. Western held them well inside red zone for a field goal. 3-0 Indiana.

SECOND SERIES (5:12 in first quarter): 3-10 twins right pistol. Chappell finds Belcher out right. 4-1 Punt.

THIRD TV SERIES: 1-10 pistol 3 WR. Bryan Payton runs up middle. Good read block by LG Justin Pagan. 2-4 pistol 2 WR. Payton up middle right. Could have been a larger gain, but RT James Brewer, who got out into the second tier, whiffed on a block of a Western linebacker. 1-10 pistol 3 WR Evans run middle. 2-3 5 WR Chappell throws right to Matt Ernest. Western tried to blitz, but it was a slow blitz. 1-10 twins left pistol. Chappell throws complete to Tandon Doss over middle. 1-10 Wildcat with Evans in backfield. Handoff to Payton, goes right. 1-10 4 WR GUN singleback Chappell over middle to Evans. 1-10 Wildcat with Evans 1 WR. Evans runs left. 2-6 pistol twins right. Payton run left, nice hole but comes just short of goal-line. Payton ran well, made up for a bad block by Mike Reiter. 1-GL Chappell QB sneak. Offensive line doesn’t help at all. Gets nothing. 2-GL Chappell QB sneak scores touchdown. 10-0 Indiana.

FOURTH SERIES: 1-10 pistol 2 WR. Playaction incomplete rolling out. 2-10 pistol 2 WR. Chappell incomplete, threw behind Doss. 3-10 pistol 2 WR. Chappell to Doss slant in left side. Doss looks like he could be elusive, but doesn’t necessarily appear to have a good step. 4thDown Punt.

FIFTH SERIES: 1-10 pistol 3 WR. McCray runs left outside. 2-6 pistol 3 WR. McCray went left, good blocking. Outran every Western defender for 59-yard touchdown. Nice run and read by McCray on the run. He wasn’t touched by anyone. Indiana leads 17-7.

SIXTH SERIES: 1-10 pistol 4 WR Chappell throws over middle to Turner. 1-10 pistol 4 WR. Chappell almost picked. Route jumped outside 2-10 pistol 4 WR. Chappell pump-faked deep. Way out of bounds. 3-10 pistol 3 WR. Draw to McCray up middle. Nice hole but Western’s defense closed in in the second tier. 4-4 Punt.

OFFENSIVE THOUGHTS: -Indiana has a bunch of running backs they can use. None, though, are as good as Brandon Minor or Carlos Brown. McCray looks pretty good and has decent speed but none of them stood out as complete burners. Then again, Willis didn’t play against Western.

-Still can’t understand why Indiana runs the pistol. The Hoosiers don’t have the speed to really run it. Chappell isn’t a particularly fast quarterback. When they got to Evans in a Wildcat-esque formation, the Pistol looks better. But I don’t think Evans, who is a wide receiver, can throw.

-This could be a big game for Brandon Graham and the defensive line. Indiana’s offensive line was unimpressive. If Michigan blitzes a decent amount, Graham will likely get freed up. Plus, Michigan’s defense plays against something like this - and probably gets better looks than Indiana will give them - whenever they go against the first team in practice.

-Doss looks like he could have some skill at receiver, but I’m not sold on his speed. No other receivers stood out from the film I watched.

DEFENSIVE THOUGHTS: -Indiana uses mostly a 4-3 front.

-Greg Middleton, who was a huge player for Indiana two years ago, looks good. He has a nice burst off the line. Western appeared to spend more time on Jammie Kirlew, though. In the second quarter, Kirlew beat his man somewhat routinely on pass plays, much like Brandon Graham did against Western.

-Overall, though, Indiana’s pressure wasn’t as impressive as Michigan’s against Western.

-Western appeared to break open holes on the Indiana front. That was a preseason concern for the Hoosiers, can they stop the run.

-Indiana’s secondary was unimpressive. They gave Western’s wide receivers a lot of cushion on underneath routes and also got beat on routes deeper in the field in the second quarter.

-Western marched down the field almost all running midway through the second quarter, including a touchdown by Western’s backup quarterback. Michigan, if it plays disciplined, should be able to run all over the Hoosiers. They are not very good at all.

-On the next series, Indiana’s run defense appeared to be a bit more stout. The defensive line, though, didn’t get too much pressure to Hiller even when they brought it.

-There were drives where Western just picked Indiana apart using run and pass balance. That was something the Broncos couldn’t do against Michigan. The Hoosiers looked on-par speed-wise or maybe even a step slower than some of Western’s players on offense. That’s bad for Indiana as most, if not all, of Michigan’s players were faster than Western’s players.

SPECIAL TEAMS: -Indiana’s kick coverage seemed to struggle. Brandon West had a couple nice returns. However, as Michigan fans saw, Darryl Stonum is much faster than West.

-Ray Fisher seems decent on kick returns, although one of his returns was called back for a block in the back.

Comments

antwaan

Wed, Sep 23, 2009 : 11:49 p.m.

Hi, I'm from Planet Klingon so I am relatively new to football. I read the box score (whatever that is)on the internet and it said that WMU ran the ball 29 times for 22 yards. Is that bad? Again, I am a complete novice so let me know if Indiana struggled against the run. I also was told that Indiana held Akron to 35 yards rushing until Akron's last drive(down by 24) against 3rd stringers. I'm guessing from your opinion, though, that they really need to work on that. And their pass rush must be bad since they're second in the league in sacks. Middleton and Kirlew have combined for over 40 sacks (most in the nation) right? I say Michigan will probably have a great day offensively and run the ball 39 times for 77 yards and have a great running game like WMU did.

maizenbluenc

Wed, Sep 23, 2009 : 3 p.m.

J Pat -- the author has been under a lot of fire for being a Notre Dame homer the past few weeks. Perhaps he's buying his way in, in Ann Arbor;-)

J Pat

Wed, Sep 23, 2009 : 2:19 p.m.

I need to call the writer out on a few things. I am an IU fan and we all know UM will most likely win this weekend. With that said, the writer needs to be more objective and not such a homer. I am not really sure he watched the game as he states above: Evans can throw, was recruited as a QB and is quite accurate. You should have done your homework there. Indiana has an O line that has given up one sack, one. Best in Big 10 so far and top 3 in nation. Yes, competition is bad but no worse than UM so far. Should have done your homework there too as you say they look unimpressive. Doss is a GREAT WR that was recruited by many D1 schools with 43, 44 speed. You say he COULD have some skill but are not sold on his speed. He is a burner. Belcher is 6 foot 5 and a beast too. Your comments like IU is not very good at all and talk about UM second team giving better looks in practice than IU in a game. That is just awful and disrespectful. I have never seen a paper in Bloomington or Indy blast your sorry past basketball teams like you did this football team. Your editor should take note of this!

azwolverine

Tue, Sep 22, 2009 : 8:15 p.m.

I hope it's a blowout for Michigan because I'd like to see Robinson and some of the other young guys get some experience. Obviously that's a lot tougher to do in a close game.

UMthicknthin

Tue, Sep 22, 2009 : 5:14 p.m.

USA today line has them +21. That's big, but 42-24 is reasonable. It's half of these kids Big 10 debut. Go Blue

A2D2

Tue, Sep 22, 2009 : 4:22 p.m.

Sounds like a Blue win! How does 31-17 sound?