You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Wed, Jan 18, 2012 : 5 a.m.

Woman regrets offer to host baby shower

By Carolyn Hax

Dear Carolyn:

My brother and his wife are expecting a little boy this spring. We're all very excited, and I've offered to host the baby shower.

The problem is that the parents-to-be are putting all kinds of conditions on the shower. They want it to be co-ed, because my sister-in-law doesn't want to have all the attention on her. They also don't want to open gifts at the shower.

I really don't like these ideas, and wish I hadn't offered to host the shower. I sincerely doubt that men want to go to a baby shower. In addition, saying you don't want to let people ooh and ahh over all the cute baby gifts is like saying, "Just leave the gift at the door."

These two have a habit of being very bad hosts when they host parties themselves. They'll turn off the heat or a/c to save money and not care about the comfort of their guests. They serve minimal food and you always leave hungry. I just don't want to be seen as an awful hostess so I can accommodate their preferences. Thanks for any guidance you can provide.

-- Baby shower dilemma

Bias is a funny thing. You see these two as bad hosts, and so you're using that lens to view their baby-shower preferences as hostile to the guests you've agreed to host. And it made (by my count) two requests into "all kinds of conditions."

As a total stranger, I don't see your brother and his wife as anything -- and I see their two requests as generous to the guests at your shower. Merciful even.

I get that showers are vehicles of tradition and that every tradition has its true believers. The argument for showers is a lovely one, too: Let the community rally to support the newcomers to a big change of life.

Anecdotally, though -- and personally, so there's my bias -- I've seen people turn on the whole institution of baby and bridal showers with increasing vehemence.

Part of it stems from diversity. Marriage and parenthood aren't the societal givens they were once perceived to be, and singletons are rightly tired of such selective celebrating.

Part of it is materialism backlash. As cheap goods and delayed family-building have made it possible for many honorees to equip their own homes without hardship, many ooh-ahh showers come across to guests as coals-to-Newcastle shams.

But the last straw is that "traditional" showers in the registry age are arguably just women watching an honoree open gift after gift after gift of things she herself picked out and knew she'd be receiving. For some, that's the social equivalent of picking cat hair out of a cable-knit sweater.

Bring the men, make it a cocktail party to celebrate parenthood, and collect the gifts on a table? A shower-fatigued singleton might feel better about buying booties for that.

This may still not be the party you'd like to host (or, ah, the hosting example you'd like to set for these two?). But you offered to host a party in their honor, and this is the party they'd be honored to attend. And what says "awful hostess" about a festive evening for family and friends? As long as you provide ample food and climate control, your reputation will emerge intact.

Email Carolyn at tellme(at), follow her on Facebook at or chat with her online at noon Eastern time each Friday at

(c) 2012, Washington Post Writers Group


Mary R. Gray

Wed, Jan 18, 2012 : 7:15 p.m.

I don't see making it a cocktail party, when expectant mothers aren't even supposed to drink. I just attended a baby shower, a very traditional one, and it was lovely. It was fun to watch the mother-to-be open the gifts, and no, she hadn't picked any of them out ahead of time. No, there were no men there, and that was OK with everyone. I rarely totally disagree with Carolyn, but this time I couldn't believe what she was saying.