Dexter-Scio fire committee plans to meet with firefighters to address concerns about plans, name
After hearing concerns from the Dexter Firefighters Association about several aspects of plan to combine the Dexter and Scio fire departments, a committee working on the consolidation wants to sit down and discuss the issues with firefighters to explain how the group reached its conclusions.
Jason Hilberer, president of the 40-member Dexter Firefighters Association, told supporters of the plan that there is uncertainty about what will happen during a transition period, and members of both departments are on edge about how the “personalities of the two departments will be meshed.”
He said firefighters aren't trying to sabotage the process; in fact, many of the Dexter firefighters are in favor of the merger.
“The merger is the right thing to do. Never has there been a concern about the caliber of the firefighters; they are both outstanding departments,” Hilberer said.
But he said as a matter of pride and tradition, firefighters want to retain the Dexter name.
The Dexter Area Fire Department serves Dexter Village, Dexter Township and Webster Township. Under the proposed consolidation with the Scio Township Fire Department, the new entity would be called Washtenaw Fire and Rescue.
Lisa Allmendinger | AnnArbor.com
“We need a new name, a fresh start, a new flag pole to rally around,” she said at a meeting last week.
Dexter Area Fire Fighters, Local 4090 President Donald Dettling asked, “Are you saying that if the name is not something other than it is, that this is the tipping point and it will outweigh everything else?”
Local 4090 is the union representing Dexter firefighters, while the association headed by Hilberer includes both current and retired firefighters.
Kelly said she understands how heartfelt the firefighters’ attitudes are about this issue. “I get it,” she said, having been through something similar while working for the auto industry.
Erica Hobbs | AnnArbor.com
Plus, members say, they want to leave the door open for other departments to join in the future.
But firefighters say there is a tradition and pride attached to their respective departments and the respective names. They calculate that changing a name on the trucks, uniforms and equipment will cost about $133,818, according to Hilberer’s figures, not including the cost for signs on the stations, letterheads and other miscellaneous items.
“It’s very important to protect something that has been around for so long when in today’s day and age people are so quick to take ownership of something and dispose of it so quickly,” Hilberer said. “Fire departments have played pivotal roles in the success of the communities which they protect.”
“Having a new name really spells out a partnership between the two departments,” said David Read, a Scio Township trustee and member of the committee. “There’s shared risk, shared sacrifice and an opportunity for it to grow in the future. How knows, maybe Chelsea or Saline will come knocking at our door?
Hilberer's hoping to get firefighters from the two departments together to talk about the plan and take the information gathered at that meeting back to the committee looking into the merger.
None of the committee members are displeased with the service they are currently receiving from the two separate departments, but their research indicates that overall, a larger, combined department would provide better service for residents and provide more opportunities for firefighters.
The proposed department would serve about 33,000 residents in Dexter Village, Dexter, Scio and Webster townships.
In the short term, both Loren Yates, Dexter's chief, and Carl Ferch, Scio's chief, will be retained and made deputy chiefs who would continue to oversee their individual departments. A new chief would then be hired to decide the operational structure of the combined department.
“We know that Scio and Dexter do things differently, that’s why we want the recommendation of the (new) chief. We don’t have the expertise to know what it takes to run a fire department,” said John Kingsley, Webster Township supervisor and a member of the committee.
Scio Township formed its own fire department in 1988, which was a decision of the elected officials in office at that time. The Dexter Fire Department traces its history back 122 years to 1890.
“I don’t see the animosity between the leadership of Scio and Dexter as there was back then,” Kingsley said.
Currently, the Dexter Area Fire Department is a 1A department, which means it responds to both life-threatening and non-life threatening calls. Scio Township is a Category 2 department, which responds to emergencies such as structure fires, cardiac arrests and motor vehicle accidents with people pinned inside.
The proposed regional department would be a 1A department, “providing the highest level of response protocol.”
How it would work
There would be quicker response times, committee members say, to certain areas of Webster Township, for instance, and all firefighters would have high levels of training.
The committee found that a combined department would allow a more efficient use of staff, equipment and apparatus. All current equipment would become the joint property of the combined department and there would be more opportunities for paid on-call firefighters and more flexibility of schedules.
All current employees would be transferred to the new department with their current date of seniority and standing. A new board, consisting of two people from each community and three from the largest community, would be chosen and a new chief would be hired.
Dexter has 28 active firefighters; seven are full-time and 21 are paid-on-call firefighters. In Scio, there are four full-time firefighters and about 15 paid-on-call firefighters.
Scio Township has the largest population at 16,470, while Dexter Village has the smallest population of the four municipalities at 4,067 people, according to the 2010 census. Webster Township ranks second in population with 6,328 residents and Dexter Township has 6,042 and is third.
Currently, the estimated costs for the combined departments are $2.208 million. That cost would be shared accordingly:
- Scio Township - 54.75 percent, or $1.209 million.
- Webster Township - 17.37 percent, or $383,500.
- Dexter Township - 15.42 percent, or about $340,000.
- Dexter Village - 12.47 percent, or about $275,380.
It is expected that the call volume in Scio Township will increase by about 25 percent with a change to a 1A department.
Here is what each community current pays for fire services:
- Scio Township: $956,250
- Webster Township: $450,556
- Dexter Township: $364,595
- Dexter Village: $437,217
With the consolidation, Scio Township will see the largest increase in costs. The combined department is expected to use five fire stations:
- Station 1 on Main Street in Dexter Village.
- Station 2 on North Territorial in Dexter Township.
- Station 3 on Webster Church Road in Webster Township.
- Station 4 on North Zeeb Road in Scio Township.
- Station 5, a planned new station at North Territorial and Dexter Townhall Road in Dexter Township.
Currently, Stations 1, 2 and 4 are manned round-the-clock, while Station 3 is being used for storage and is not staffed.
Some Webster Township officials have had questions about the benefits of this plan for their residents, and the committee issued a four-page letter to address their concerns.
It is expected that there will be a discussion on this topic Tuesday night at the monthly township board meeting.
Scio Township has already adopted a resolution in support of the concept and it's expected that the Dexter Village Council will see something similar on its agenda in the next month.
Lisa Allmendinger is a regional reporter for AnnArbor.com. She can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. For more Dexter area stories, visit our Dexter page.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 8:06 p.m.
Whatever they decide for a new name I just hope it doesn't change one tradition. The Dexter Daze Beer Tent (or "social tent" as they are trying to refer to it now) better stay as it is!! Just saying ;)
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 8:59 p.m.
for those who are not aware, the social tent at the Dexter Daze summer celebration is a fund raiser for the fire dept and so the firefighters serve the drinks. It is something of a class reunion so to speak for Dexter graduates who meet there each summer and catch up with one another.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 5:58 p.m.
The negotiators in Dexter village, Township and Webster township must be pretty good. My elected officials in Scio must be crazy to force their citizens to may more....But wait...Scio Township approved a pretty big public service millage two years ago. I guess the elected officials in Scio are no different than anywhere else...can't wait to spend other people's money.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 5:48 p.m.
I believe we should embrace the firefighter's wishes in regards to keeping their traditional name. It is very important for the firefighter's to take pride in their department and their job as a whole. If keeping their name is good for their moral, then let's not mess with it. I would rather have my firefighters be in good spirits and mood, then not. I know they will do a good job either way, but lets embrace them. When I think of the name "Dexter area", I think of the Village as the hub, and the surrounding townships included. Scio Township use to be serviced by this department, with the Dexter Area department name. If there is future growth, with Chelsea City and their surrounding townships, we simply add another name to the original. Example: "Dexter-Chelsea Area fire department". The whole idea of this merger is to save money, lets not waste our taxpayers money, by re-lettering the firetrucks, fire stations, uniforms, etc... When I think of names such as: "Western Washtenaw fire department", I think of the Western Washtenaw Recycling service. Not a very good comparison in my mind.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 5:58 p.m.
Totally agree with BBC. At a time that our fire departments and police departments are being made to take major concessions, especially by Governor Snyder. The least we can do, is show our support and let them keep their name. Doesn't cost us anything, but actually saves money.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 1:52 p.m.
The name should not be an insurmountable issue. There are large metropolitan and county-based fire departments across the United States that protect different communities, yet find ways to allow their crews to have station pride. FDNY has an official department-wide patch that everyone wears on their uniforms and is displayed on apparatus. They also allow individual engine, squad, ladder, and rescue companies to have their own patch to recognize their specific unit. Baltimore County Fire Department has "Baltimore County Fire Department" on all of their apparatus, but also has additional lettering identifying the community the specific piece of apparatus is assigned to protect. Similar set-ups can be found in Los Angeles-CA, Loveland-Symmes-OH, Denver-CO, Lewisville-TX, and countless other departments. The merging of Dexter and Scio is a good thing, please look to other fire departments nationally that have company pride but recognize the unity of their larger organization.
Mon, Feb 20, 2012 : 1:36 p.m.
Pretending that Scio didn't breakaway - rather arrogantly - isn't helping. That being said, great, let's merge again into the DAFD. There's enough growth and new people not to be dragged down by history. There's no reason why the name needs to be different. At the time I wasn't a fan of Loren. But he does seem to have lead the DAFD through a time of significant growth. No reason not to consider him for the new job. Don't know Carl, but not sure why we wouldn't consider him, too.