You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 6 a.m.

Ann Arbor Country Club sued by mortgage buyer's rep over vote to lower rates, leadership

By Paula Gardner

Members of Ann Arbor Country Club hope that lower rates this season will attract more people to the facility, raising the number of participants to levels that generate enough funds to cover operations and debt.

Meeting the club’s financial obligations also is the goal of the club’s board of directors and new mortgage investor, according to court documents.

But how each side reaches that goal headed into litigation in late March, with a filing in Washtenaw County Circuit Court by Michael Weikle against the club and the board members who also formed a group to try to buy the mortgage.

020310_ANN ARBOR COUNTRY CLUB 3-3 LON.jpg

The Ann Arbor Country Club in late winter.

Lon Horwedel | AnnArbor.com

Weikle, a resident of the Loch Alpine neighborhood that surrounds the 200-acre Webster Township club, represented mortgage buyer A2C2 LLC, based in West Virginia.

A2C2 paid $625,000 for the $1.7 million note that Citizens Bank told the club it would sell after the club went into default.

The transaction took place March 5, two days after Weikle and the investor - listed on West Virginia records as Lewis Whaley - committed to buying the mortgage.

That transaction, however, came as AACC board president Karen Stevens and six other club members were pursuing additional investors as part of a group called Mag7 Properties Inc., formed to submit a bid on the club’s mortgage.

Since then, Mag7 disbanded and AACC’s board called an April 1 meeting to vote on two measures: Dropping rates for 2010 and giving the board authority to file for bankruptcy or take the club into foreclosure.

Both measures passed, according to AACC attorney Joe Phillips of Ann Arbor.

But Weikle challenged that meeting in the lawsuit filed March 23, and also asks that any board members connected to Mag7 be removed from office.

The dues change, he said in the filing, “put the club at further and almost certain risk of not being able to make any payments on its loans to A2C2.”

The plan to cut the rates without a corresponding marketing plan, according to the lawsuit, is “formula for certain financial disaster.”

The lawsuit also says that his communication with Stevens on behalf of A2C2 failed to disclose her role in Mag7, raising questions about whether she and others should be making decisions on behalf of the club while part of the investment group.

Now Weikle said he’s trying to protect that investment by ensuring that the club makes enough changes to attract new revenue.

“Let’s bring people in and increase membership and ensure that the club survives,” he said in an interview.

Phillips, in a response to the lawsuit that was filed March 30, said Weikle facilitated the mortgage purchase by A2C2 immediately after learning that Mag7 was close to making an offer.

Weikle, in documents, is also accused of “meddling in the Club’s internal affairs by engaging in unauthorized meetings with Club employees.”

The April 1 vote to allow the board to file bankruptcy or enter foreclosure comes because the $1.7 million debt - described in the filing as “onerous” - meant that the board decided to consider its options.

With the purchase of the mortgage, A2C2 and the club must negotiate payment terms. The original debt remains, Weikle said, and isn’t affected by the discounted purchase price that A2C2 obtained from Citizen’s Bank.

“The club’s already agreed to the $1.7 million,” Weikle said. “That’s what they borrowed. We feel the asset’s worth $1.7 million.”

However, terms - such as the interest rate and payment schedule - could be negotiated, he said.

Those negotiations, he said, need to take place with board members who did not pursue the mortgage purchase outside of their board duties.

The Ann Arbor Country Club said the lawsuit is an “attempt to obtain an unfair advantage in negotiations between A2C2 and The Club.”

Weikle, in turn, said he doesn’t want the club to go into bankruptcy. He’s a former member who still has $2,700 in club equity that hasn’t been refunded, and he’s been concerned about the dwindling membership over recent years.

“My investor doesn’t want to run a country club,” he said. “… (We) don’t want to make decisions for the club…. But I do think we need fresh ideas. No matter what you come up with, the investor has to have some comfort level.”

A hearing will be held at 1:30 p.m. April 28 in front of Judge David Swartz. The new rates have not been posted on the AACC website; however, the club did open March 17.

Meanwhile, Mag7 was dissolved as of April 2, according to state documents.

Weikle said he wants the club to survive.

“The worst solution for all of us is a judicial solution,” he said.

Paula Gardner is Business News Director of AnnArbor.com. Contact her at 734-623-2586 or by email. Sign up for the weekly Business Review newsletter, distributed every Thursday, here.

Comments

SW333T

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 10:32 a.m.

So the board president and board members were reviewing outside offers to purchase the club yet at the same time they were pursuing their own purchase through Mag7? Is this even legal? No wonder he wants to clean house and get a fresh start.

Chelsea

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 9:52 a.m.

Interesting - and sad at the same time. We belonged a few years back - I remember that the board was difficult way back then - I wonder if it's the same people? They were very opposed to change, and seemed to want to run it by their own rules - which didn't necessarily benefit or even take the opinions of the members into account. Sounds to me like a reorganization would be nothing but beneficial to this beautiful club - we might even join again!

Summer

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 9 a.m.

What about the former members that will come back because the rates are now reasonable? I believe they will have more members coming back than leaving. Ann Arbor Country Club needs all new people on the Board who are not married to the golf course. Fresh blood = fresh ideas. The residents need the club to thrive and the club needs the residents to help them thrive.

John Alan

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 7:52 a.m.

Purchasing the notes on this property for $625K was a fantastic investment. If the new owner takes over the property and under new management/ownership (or even leasing/partnering at good lease rate to an experianced operator --- based on the purchase price) they will do just fine.... Then even, lowering the membership rates and/or fees still will be profitable!!! I guess sometimes in business ONE has to decide and go rather than having meeting and voting and meeting for the meeting and adding cost and expense to make all the board members happy does not cut it.... This is a business... either it makes money and stays or needs to pack and go.... In business (at some point) got to stop the cash bleeding and start making money otherwise, the ship will sink!! I hope things can resolved between the note holder and the members... for sure spending money on legal fees will not help the club.

belboz

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 7:52 a.m.

For the acreage, $1.7 million is a pretty good deal. I bet they would be happy to develop it some day. That is what will happen.

scooter dog

Wed, Apr 7, 2010 : 7:32 a.m.

So what happens when the 200 or so residents stop being paying members of aacc.Nothing says they have to continue being members.Then what happens to his investment?