You are viewing this article in the archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see
Posted on Tue, May 15, 2012 : 5:59 a.m.

Menards store: Planners approve rezoning request for Scio Township store

By Lizzy Alfs

Menard Inc. is one step closer to building a 162,000-square-foot home improvement store on Jackson Road just west of Ann Arbor.

The Scio Township Planning Commission voted 6-0 Monday night to approve a rezoning request for a 62-acre site on the southeast corner of Jackson and Staebler Roads, just west of the Meijer store at Jackson and Zeeb. Commissioner Celeste Novak was absent from the meeting.


Menards wants to build a store on Jackson Road in Scio Township.

Source: Facebook


The 165-acre site, located at the intersection of Jackson and Staebler, is known as the former Farmer Grant land.

Lizzy Alfs |

Menards is under contract to purchase the site from property owners Mel Vanderbrug and Don Colone. The property — also known as the former Farmer Grant land — is a portion of a 165-acre site that previously was eyed for development as part of The Village at Honey Creek.

The land was conditionally zoned for that project, and Menards requested to rezone the 62-acre site that fronts Jackson Road to straight general commercial.

The request — which the township first considered at its April 23 meeting — passed with little discussion among the commissioners.

Township Planner Doug Lewan said the few conditions the planning staff has, such as issues related to sewer service, can be addressed when Menards submits site plans for the project.

At the same time, the commissioners voted 5-1 to revert the conditional zoning for the remainder of the property back to its original designation: general agriculture.

The reversion was necessary, Lewan said, because the conditions of The Village at Honey Creek development cannot now be met.

“With the Menards land out of the picture, some of the phases of the original development are no longer possible,” Lewan said. “Our zoning ordinance is pretty specific on what we are able to do at this point…we are to revert the zoning back to its original designation.”

Dana Dever, a local attorney representing the Grants — who still own some acreage on the site behind the Menards property — said he has people interested in a residential development for the Grants’ portion of the property.

If the site is reverted back to general agriculture, he’s concerned about the time and cost involved in rezoning the property again.

“We are attempting to find an alternative path that would, in essence, preserve what’s there,” he said. “Rather than going to agriculture, can you preserve the portions of multi-family residential zoning that are relevant and practical?” he asked.

Lewan said for Dever and his clients to rezone the property for a residential development — which they have already requested to do — it would only require they submit a conceptual plan, not a full site plan.

“They have the option to request a conditional rezoning, and for a conditional rezoning, we do not require a full site plan, which would be somewhat expensive,” Lewan said. “We need, basically, a concept plan.”

Both the Menards rezoning request and the revert-back zoning will now go before the Scio Township Board of Trustees.

If the Menards rezoning request is approved, the applicant will still have to get special land use approval for the site, and then address issues such as the impact to neighboring communities, Lewan said.

Although site plans for the Menards store are still in preliminary stages, the store would likely only account for 16 of the 62-acres the company is looking to purchase. The rest is expected to be used for open space, buffering and other developments, such as restaurants or a small medical complex.

The Wisconsin-based company, which has 262 locations in 13 states, including nine locations in Michigan, filed a rezoning request with Pittsfield Township in 2010 to build a store at 4700 Carpenter Road.

The Pittsfield Township Planning Commission voted to deny the rezoning request from light industrial to commercial, and the Board of Trustees then voted to accept the recommendation.

After the request was denied, Menards confirmed it would continue to search for a location in Washtenaw County.

The company is also currently looking to build stores in Warren, Livonia and Kalamazoo County, and is in various stages of approval for rezoning requests and site plans for those stores.

Lizzy Alfs is a business reporter for Reach her at 734-623-2584 or email her at Follow her on Twitter at



Tue, May 15, 2012 : 3:47 p.m.

Overall, I think this is very good news. Menards has a great selection of products and has very good pricing on many items. But as one person posted, you always need to be aware of quality when shopping these big box stores. Even some of their brand name lines are actually cheaper versions of each company's better products. It beats me why these manufacturers would knowingly damage their own brand image by doing that. But, I've had several poor experiences buying what I thought were good products at places like Lowes and Home Depot and they didn't last very long. So, my advice is shop carefully and smartly at places like Menards when they open.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 2:22 p.m.

Menards will be good for a few jobs, but it'll be tough on local small businesses like hardware stores, Fingerle lumber etc.....but the smart, quality builders and DIY types know quality can only be found at those stores. I've shopped at them all, for decades, here's my list... Fingerle Lumber Co, absolute tops in all categories, quality, price, knowledgeable staff, easy access to product for loading, many people there to help with product selection, as well as a wide base of top quality product . Lowe's, several steps down the quality level as compared to Fingerle, but all areas covered (building, electrical, plumbing, garden, appliance, etc.) "ok" quality, good hours, a few (not many) knowledgeable people. Pretty much same goes for Home Depot, messy old arrangement though, not many people around to help, almost none knowledgeable. The bottom of the list is Menards, most product is bottom end..with a price to truly get what you pay for, they have darn near everything you could want (Chinese produced).

Zach Jerger

Tue, May 15, 2012 : 7:52 p.m.

There is a lot more American made products sold at Menards than at Home Depot/Lowes. This is one of their key marketing tools.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 2:19 p.m.

More Building, More Building, More Building ... how about the lazy citizens of A2 and surrounding areas drive to the establishments that are already established. We do not need another store.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 1:55 p.m.



Tue, May 15, 2012 : 12:49 p.m.

finally scio did something right. let casco go. should be a nice addition. now all we need is bike paths (bad idea)


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 4:09 p.m.

Yeah, what? How are bike paths a bad idea? Perhaps you are talking about downsizing roadways to add bike LANES? Path's imply a separate trail, and where they will be used, generally represent an excellent idea.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 3:35 p.m.

Bike paths: the route away from obesity towards sustainability. Deal with it, as we deal with your tonnage-on-four wheels all the time.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 1:54 p.m.

Shhh!! Don't say bike paths...lets not let that disease spread any further than Ann Arbor!


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 10:52 a.m.

This is good news. The closest Menards is in Jackson. Menards is a nice addition to the area. They are not the same as Home Depot or Lowes.


Tue, May 15, 2012 : 7:19 p.m.

Yes they are. It's a big box home improvement store.