You are viewing this article in the AnnArbor.com archives. For the latest breaking news and updates in Ann Arbor and the surrounding area, see MLive.com/ann-arbor
Posted on Sun, Oct 9, 2011 : 8:03 p.m.

Michigan's execution in short-yardage, third-down situations keys Northwestern win, 6-0 start

By Kyle Meinke

DenardRobinson_ShortYards.jpg

Michigan faced 11 third- or fourth-down situations needing 3 yards or fewer against Northwestern. Quarterback Denard Robinson, above, got the call seven times and picked up a first down or touchdown all but once.

Melanie Maxwell | AnnArbor.com

EVANSTON, Ill. -- For the second time this season, Michigan football coach Brady Hoke called timeout with his team facing a 4th-and-short on its side of the 50-yard line.

Both times, he had sent out his punt team. Both times, the Wolverines retook the field with their offense. Both times, they converted.

It's a microcosm of why Michigan has been so good on offense this year: Its ability to consistently convert short-yardage plays, especially on third and fourth down.

No. 11 Michigan beat Northwestern 42-24 on Saturday to move to 6-0 and 2-0 in Big Ten play. In the game, it converted 14 of its 17 third-down attempts, including nine of 10 in the second half. It also converted its only fourth-down attempt.

The Wolverines are converting 58.1 percent of their third-down tries this season, which is third-best in the country. Against Northwestern, they were even better when needing 3 yards or fewer, picking up a first down or touchdown 72.7 percent of the time.

How has Michigan been so effective on these crucial, drive-sustaining plays?

It comes back, as it so often does, to quarterback Denard Robinson.

Michigan faced 11 third- or fourth-down situations needing 3 yards or fewer to achieve a first down or touchdown. Every time, offensive coordinator Al Borges elected to run the ball, with Robinson getting the bulk of those carries.

The junior quarterback got the call seven times, and picked up a first down or touchdown each time except once.

The Wolverines have one of the country's top rushing attacks -- it's currently ranked seventh -- which clearly is paying off in terms of sustaining drives and time of possession.

On the flip side, Michigan's defense is getting stops on these plays. After not allowing a third-down conversion against Minnesota last week, the Wolverines held Northwestern to 4-of-11 on third down and 0-of-2 on fourth down conversions this week.

Hoke has said most stats mean little to him, but one that does is getting third-down stops at about a 63- or 64-percent clip. His team is at 61 percent, but has been air-tight the past three weeks.

Against Northwestern, that kept the Wolverines' defense off the field and the ball out of the hands of the Wildcats' best player, quarterback Dan Persa. That was particularly true in the third quarter, when Northwestern had just two four-play drives.

The first ended with a three-and-out punt and the second with an interception by linebacker Brandin Hawthorne.

Michigan converted all four of its third downs in that quarter.

"I don’t know what time of possession was, to be honest with you, but I know in the third quarter our offense had the ball a while and the defense did a pretty good job getting the ball back," Hoke said.

The Wolverines held the ball for 12 minutes, 28 seconds of the third quarter and 37:57 overall. They're 28th nationally this year in time of possession after being 116th last season.

And, as several players have noted, this not only helps to score points, but prevent Michigan's defense from allowing them. Senior defensive tackle Ryan Van Bergen said last week his playing time has been reduced by as much as half in some games this year as compared to last year.

That bodes very well for Michigan as it prepares to face its toughest defense of the year in Michigan State. The Spartans feature the country's top overall defense, and they're No. 3 against the run.

So, it'll be the country's No. 7 rushing offense against the No. 3 rushing defense. Who wins?


Gardner_Robinson_NW.jpg

Michigan's two-quarterback formation of Devin Gardner (7) and Denard Robinson (16) was not as effective against Northwestern as it was against Minnesota.

Melanie Maxwell | AnnArbor.com

'Two-quarterbacks' gets
mixed reviews

Michigan's two-quarterback formation, which puts backup quarterback Devin Gardner under center while Robinson remains on the field, was not as effective against Northwestern as it was against Minnesota.

Robinson lined up as a receiver this week after being in the backfield against Minnesota. This seems to be a less effective place for him, because it's unlikely Michigan would send him down field to catch passes -- and especially not over the middle. His options at wideout largely are limited to being used as a decoy or getting the ball on a reverse.

When Robinson is in the backfield, any number of plays could use him effectively, whether or not he touches the ball.

Still, the tweak in the formation serves the important purpose of giving Michigan State, the Wolverines' next opponent, a few more wrinkles for which to prepare. Robinson has been in the backfield and now at wideout, and Gardner has been a capable quarterback, whether he's throwing or running.

That's a strategic advantage for Michigan, considering the Spartans already have an extra week for game planning because they are coming off their bye week.


BlakeCountess_Minn.jpg

Freshman Blake Countess (18) played well against Minnesota, above, and was on the field early against Northwestern on Saturday.

Melanie Maxwell | AnnArbor.com

Countess' stock rising
Freshman cornerback Blake Countess turned 18 just two days before the start of fall camp. Now, he appears to be cracking the regular rotation on Michigan's revamped defense.

Senior cornerback Troy Woolfolk has started every game this year. However, it didn't take long for Countess to replace him on the field against Northwestern, playing alongside junior J.T. Floyd. The Michigan Radio Network reported the move was not because of injury. This means a few things.

• Either Woolfolk's various injuries are setting him back -- he's dealing with a sprained left ankle and broken right hand -- or Countess simply is pulling even with him in terms of performance. Or some combination of the two.

• Floyd is Michigan's undisputed top cornerback right now. This has become clear in recent weeks, as opposing quarterbacks have preferred to throw toward the corner opposite Floyd, but coaches seem to be embracing this as well.

• Countess has surpassed sophomore Courtney Avery as the third cornerback.

Countess has played remarkably well since getting his first defensive snaps against San Diego State. He allowed his first touchdown against Northwestern, getting beat on a fade to the corner of the end zone, but it still took a perfect throw to get it over him.

Coaches have been slightly reserved in their praise of Countess, despite his solid play. That could mean they are high on him and expect him to get more time in coming weeks, but don't want to build up expectations.

That would be the most logical explanation for why they would undersell what otherwise has been an impeccable debut.


Mattison_Hoke_NW.jpg

Defensive coordinator Greg Mattison, left, and head coach Brady Hoke, right, simplified their defensive schemes in the second half against Northwestern.

Melanie Maxwell | AnnArbor.com

Michigan goes big, goes low
Hoke said there were a couple specific defensive changes executed at halftime: He and defensive coordinator Greg Mattison elected to simplify their schemes, and they settled on a nickel sub-package as their primary personnel grouping.

"We went to a bigger group ... where a bigger-bodied guy could engage the receivers out there and maybe make something happen," Hoke said.

So, Michigan went with three linebackers and a true 4-3, instead of five defensive backs, which had not been working against the option that was shredding Michigan's defense. That put Jake Ryan, a big-bodied linebacker who plays on the strong side, on the field.

Sure enough, he blew up the first option of the second half, and Michigan didn't allow a point after halftime.

Michigan's in-game adjustments continue to pan out at an astounding rate. It's now outscoring opponents 114-21 in the second half.


Standing Pat
Northwestern coach Pat Fitzgerald, when asked about the personal foul he picked up after Persa was whistled down on a 4th-down play because his helmet had come off: "I have to worry about three kids' college funds, so I'll leave it at that."


MichaelShaw_NW.jpg

Senior running back Michael Shaw (20) scores a touchdown during the fourth quarter of Michigan's 42-24 win at Northwestern on Saturday.

Melanie Maxwell | AnnArbor.com

Hello, Michael Shaw
Senior tailback Michael Shaw has slid up and down the Wolverines' depth chart more than anyone this year, going from the favorite to win the tailback job in fall camp to getting one combined carry in blowouts of Eastern Michigan and San Diego State.

Now, he's received eight carries against Minnesota and six against Northwestern. Important ones, too. He scored Michigan's first touchdown of the fourth quarter against the Wildcats, extending the Wolverines' lead from 28-24 to 35-24.

He received twice as many carries as junior Vincent Smith (three), who has complemented sophomore Fitz Toussaint as Michigan's primary ball carriers.

Why now?

It might be because of Shaw's speed. He's the quickest of Michigan's backs, and Northwestern was stopping runs up the middle. Toussaint, for instance, had 14 carries for only 30 yards.

Is Shaw here to stay? Likely not. Toussaint and Smith seem to be the Wolverines' best options. But, it appears the staff won't hesitate to go to him if matchups dictate it.


Player tweet
Senior tight end Kevin Koger, who uses the handle @KogerNotKroger, after the game:

"Nothing needs to be said lol"


MSU_OSU.jpg

Up next for Michigan: The nation's top-ranked defense.

AP Photo

Look ahead
The water cooler talk Monday morning: Can Michigan beat Michigan State for the first time in four years?

As was the case against Northwestern, and San Diego State before it, and Notre Dame before that, this will be Michigan's biggest test so far this year. It's in East Lansing. The Wolverines are playing well, but Michigan State has the country's top overall defense and an extra week to prepare because of an off week.

This is going to be a tough one to call, but if Robinson can limit his turnovers, Michigan should have a great shot at moving to 7-0 with its off week looming, then a home game against Purdue after that.

Michigan State's defense is so good, the Wolverines cannot afford to squander scoring opportunities. Conversely, the Spartans' offense has struggled so much, they may have a hard time scoring if Michigan doesn't give them a short field.

Turnovers will be a major key in this game -- as they so often are in rivalries.

Kyle Meinke covers Michigan football for AnnArbor.com. He can be reached at 734-623-2588, by email at kylemeinke@annarbor.com and followed on Twitter @kmeinke.

Comments

umgoblue47

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 7:44 p.m.

this is going to be a close game and the team with the least turnovers and penalties should win this game. . . the weather could also factor into this as rain is forcast in EL on saturday. . . GO BLUE!!!!!!!

missionbrazil

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 5:14 p.m.

I am optimistic about our chances against MSU. Their D is good, but then again ND put up 31 points on them. That ND game showed that MSU is very beatable. Even though their O averages 28 points per game, they have only scored 23 points in 2 games against good/decent teams (ND and OSU). It will be a good battle for quite awhile, but we should pull away from them late in the 3rd quarter or in the 4th and get the win. Go Blue !

EyeonAA

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 4:08 p.m.

MSU basketball and football improved as their Michigan counterparts regressed. Good thing the football situation was addressed before it got to be as bad as the basketball situation.

DonAZ

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 2:31 p.m.

Before the season I kept making the point in comments on this forum that the key to Michigan in 2011 was not so much how many victories, but rather *how* the victories were achieved. So far in 2011 we have seen Michigan secure a victory in every game, which is a very nice thing. But more importantly, as others have said, Michigan is securing those victories with adjustments during the games and improvements one week to the next. The coaching staff's insistence on toughness and sound fundamentals is paying off. Personally I think the 3rd down conversion rate is one of the most important -- both what the offense is capable of converting and what the defense prevents. It's a key indicator of the overall health of a team. I do not think Michigan is a top-ten team yet. But I believe they will get there. Perhaps not this year. But eventually. By the six or seventh game of last year I had given up hope on the previous coaching staff.

Blu-dogg97

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 2:51 p.m.

agreed DonAZ .. last year I had given up on the coaching staff also.. of 40 yrs of watching Michigan FB games,I never went out and mowed the lawn or washed the car during Michigan games,like i did last yr.. could hardly watch some of those debacles.

Blu-dogg97

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 2:12 p.m.

These stats don't lie,and Michigan is improving each week. Michigan's in-game adjustments continue to pan out at an astounding rate. It's now outscoring opponents 114-21 in the second half... The Wolverines are converting 58.1 percent of their third-down tries this season, which is third-best in the country. Against Northwestern, they were even better when needing 3 yards or fewer, picking up a first down or touchdown 72.7 percent of the time. it converted 14 of its 17 third-down attempts, including nine of 10 in the second half. It also converted its only fourth-down attempt. Granted MSU has a very good defense vs some sub par opponents this year, except for ND,and we know how that turned out ! The halftime coaching adjustments are the key to me, and they have been amazing turn arounds in the second half,of the ball games.. Is Persa better than Cousins ? yes, even if he's not 100%, Is Persa better in the open field than Cousins as a dual threat ? yes imo .. I feel MSU will not be able to score enough,specially in the 2nd half, they're offense has been anemic at best,so I believe Michigan's coaching staff ,and D-Rob's abilities will be advantage Michigan ! Has anybody noticed Big Will has been improving also? he had a dramatic sack against Minn,and I wonder what Persa was thinking when he saw the 330lb monster in Big Will pancaking him in the 4th qtr of the last game ? The coaching staff is really challenging him! and thats the best thing to happen to Big Will in his collegiate career.. GO BLUE..

truebluefan

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 1:51 p.m.

I love how our coaching staff is comprised of over-achievers. These guys want to make a statement every game and they will step on throats to achieve that goal. Michigan is great again for the gamblers since they're covering the spread every game! The Carr years were pretty bad for gambling Michigan fans.

Matt Patercsak

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 3:27 a.m.

I love the direction this team is headed, everything about it is headed towards a traditional michigan powerhouse program. the new away jerseys were plain white, and the yellow stripe along the lower back was gone. we put our hands in the dirt on short yardage and convert. we push people at the line of scrimmage and we have full usage of fullbacks! I for one am sick of MSU fans talking about how "legit" their spartans are. their time as Big 10 co champs is screeching to a halt. and the universe is coming back into alignment. if UofM wins on saturday, I will have the utmost confidence in our team to make it to the big ten championship game. the nightmare will be over.

Mick

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 2:45 a.m.

Trust me when I say that if MSU wins, they will feel lucky to do so, I think we have a better team and their cute little 3 year run was because of the previous inept staff, they're gone now and things have changed drastically. The future is looking bright, I like our chances in every game this year. Let me pose this question, Wiscy beat Neb and we beat ND, who would win in a game between ND and Neb right now? Maybe the home team? I would give ND a better chance at Neb than the other way around. So I'm getting tired of people dismissing our schedule and it's always the next game is the real test, I've been having to listen to that all season, we've played some pretty good games against some pretty good teams.

azwolverine

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 1:28 a.m.

You know it, Theodora. We may not win every game, but we are certainly moving in the right direction. Go Blue!

TIC

Mon, Oct 10, 2011 : 12:28 a.m.

Can't wait to see how we fare in ELansing. WIN or lose, we are moving in the right direction. We have a solid plan on both sides of the ball. Just have to keep executing in the face of adversity.